If C.S. Lewis would have studied Islam, here's what he would have found.
C.S.
A. C. Rosenthal
Investigating Islam, Christianity, and the West — one primary source at a time.
Live Last read · last published · next check
Latest episodes
The Argument Before the Film
What the Fight Over Nolan’s Odyssey Was Really About, and the Right to Deface an Inheritance.
The Prophets Before the Seven Woes
4th of 4 pieces on testing false prophets and lying spirits
THE MAN WHO CHANGED HIS MIND, AND THE MAN WHO DIDN’T
A Response to Dr. Craig Considine, 2014 and 2025, who has earned my respect.
God does not argue you into the room. He puts something in front of you and trusts your eyes.
*THE GOD THEY REJECTED ISN’T REAL* series 40-75
The Quran Is an Incomplete Sentence
Part 3 of 4. Testing false prophets and lying spirits
The art of suicidal math and the last stand at Masada: A thought experiment
The modern oath of a reborn nation "Masada shall not fall again" defies Islam's hatred of all things Jewish. God bless Israel!
The Caricature in the Mirror
*THE GOD THEY REJECTED ISN’T REAL* series 39-75
The Prophet Who Knew The Least
Part 2 of 4. Testing prophets and spirits
Darwins Dark Road
The Test They Would Not Run
Nobody Asked the Spirit About Jesus
Part 1 of 4, Testing false prophets and lying spirits
The Hallmark Card Prayer
*THE GOD THEY REJECTED ISN’T REAL* series 38b-75
Everything we know about Troy, we know from people who were not Trojans.
Glory fades. Strength fails. Even the greatest fall. But there is something that remains—the man who carries his brother-in-arms from the field.
What Seeking Actually Looks Like
*THE GOD THEY REJECTED ISN’T REAL* series 38-75
An aid to memory
I've put together an easier way to commit something to memory, The question is will it survive contact with the public?
John Paul 2. Judge Them All by their fruit.
As Supreme Pontiff, John Paul II was not merely a man of God—he was a statesman, a philosopher, and a lightning rod for change , and what it reveals about measuring a faith by its fruit.
What happens when religion cosplays as fantasy?
From Middle-earth to the real world.
From Projection to Encounter
*THE GOD THEY REJECTED ISN’T REAL* series 37-75
They Were Always Looking for Someone They Already Knew
A response to “Where Did Religion Come From?” by Let the Stones Speak
Has Pain Become Your Theology?
*THE GOD THEY REJECTED ISN’T REAL* series 36-75