Ancient Jewish history is disappearing without anyone destroying the archaeology. The stones, tombs, ancient cities, inscriptions, biblical references, archaeological layers, and millennia of written history remain intact. Only the language around them changes.
I’m on a mission as a history activist to document Jewish history before it’s rewritten, distorted, or erased. Every paid subscription helps fund the research behind these essays and enables me to continue this work full-time. For $75 a year (just 21¢ a day), you’re doing more than supporting a writer. You’re helping preserve the Jewish story.
An ancient Jewish site becomes a “Palestinian heritage site.” Samaria becomes Sebastia. The Cave of the Patriarchs becomes the Ibrahimi Mosque. Places are described according to the political authority claiming them today. That contemporary designation travels backward through centuries it never belonged to. The State of Palestine places ancient sites inside a Palestinian national framework through UNESCO, including places whose Jewish or Israelite history is acknowledged in the Palestinian submissions themselves. Eventually, readers encounter an ancient place through its newest identity first. History is reassigned without moving a single stone.
As of July 2026, a new example sits at the center of this story.
Several shifts occur simultaneously. A current geographic label attaches to an ancient site. That label becomes an identity label. The identity is then projected backward onto people who lived millennia before it existed. The physical site remains exactly where it was, while its history is gradually reorganized around a present-day claim.
The terms Palestine, Palestinian, and State of Palestine are increasingly treated as interchangeable across time, collapsing distinct categories:
Palestine serves as a geographic and administrative name in various forms across centuries.
Palestinian describes a national identity with a much later development.
The State of Palestine is a contemporary political designation.
Collapsing these categories transforms a site located in territory claimed by the State of Palestine into a Palestinian site. This site then becomes evidence of ancient Palestinian history. People who lived thousands of years ago receive a contemporary nationality after death.
UNESCO’s current listings accelerate this process. The State of Palestine holds six properties inscribed on the World Heritage List and another 22 on its Tentative List. Those 22 include Qumran, Herodium, Mount Gerizim, and, as of January 2026, a group literally named “Canaanite city-states.”
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.