Donald Trump has managed to do something remarkable: make a trade war with America’s closest neighbor so reckless that even conservative media figures are struggling to defend it.
After negotiations with Canada collapsed, the Trump administration imposed 50 percent tariffs on roughly $20 billion in Canadian goods. Trump then threatened to extend 50 percent tariffs to Canadian cars, trucks and auto parts beginning January 1. Canada has promised dollar-for-dollar retaliation starting September 8, raising the prospect of a spiraling economic conflict between two countries whose workers, manufacturers and supply chains are deeply connected.
This is not economic strength. It is chaos dressed up as toughness—and American families could be left paying the bill.
We’ll break down everything you need to know about Trump’s trade war with our northern neighbor below.
In a Fox Business segment I highlight, a guest dismantled one of Trump’s favorite arguments: that the trade deficit with Canada proves the United States is being cheated.
Much of that deficit comes from the heavy Canadian crude American refineries are designed to process. Remove that essential energy trade, the guest explained, and the picture looks very different. Then came the line Republicans should not be able to ignore: “Tariff is another word for tax.”
That is the heart of the matter. Tariffs are collected from importers, and those added costs can travel through supply chains to businesses and consumers. They can raise the price of vehicles, construction materials, food and countless everyday products. Trump can call the policy leverage, patriotism or negotiation. At the checkout counter, it can still feel like a tax.
Even The Wall Street Journal editorial board has had enough. Last year, it called Trump’s fight with Canada and Mexico “the dumbest trade war in history.” In a new editorial, the paper said the conflict “got dumber” when Trump escalated again just weeks before the midterm elections.
When one of the country’s most influential conservative editorial pages is warning that a Republican president’s signature trade policy makes no economic or political sense, the White House has a serious problem.
Canada is not an enemy. It is a NATO ally, a crucial trading partner and a country that stood with the United States after September 11. More than 40,000 members of the Canadian Armed Forces served in Afghanistan, and 158 Canadian service members were killed.
Now Trump is treating that ally like an adversary. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has called the escalating dispute a trade war, while Ontario Premier Doug Ford has warned that electricity and critical minerals could be part of Canada’s response. According to the Associated Press, Ford says “everything is on the table.”
That retaliation could hurt Americans, too. U.S. and Canadian auto production is so integrated that parts routinely cross the border during manufacturing. Reuters reports that industry leaders are warning the disruption could threaten American assembly lines.
Trump promised to lower costs. Instead, he is creating new uncertainty for families, farmers, manufacturers and small businesses. He promised competent dealmaking. Instead, he is provoking retaliation from a friend and forcing his own media allies to explain why his policy does not add up.
Democrats should make the choice plain: one party is defending affordable goods, stable supply chains and strong alliances. The other is asking Americans to absorb the cost of Donald Trump’s grudges.
The most revealing part of this story is not simply that Canada is angry. It is that the economic case against Trump’s trade war has become so obvious that it is breaking through on Fox and in the pages of The Wall Street Journal.
When even the right can no longer pretend the emperor’s tariff policy is working, voters should pay attention.
-Ethan
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.