I was in high school during the September 11 terrorist attacks of the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. Like those of another generation witnessing the Kennedy assassination, I vividly recall where I was.
I was in chorus, taught by a man I found annoying at the best of times, and loathsome at the worst. There were murmurs among the teachers, and he put on the TV. Throughout our classes, we watched, unbelieving, as the planes crashed through the New York skyline, one after other.
We all had our guesses, our assumptions, our ways of dealing with a shared trauma. I skipped school for a few days after, dissociating like most of the country. The skies were silent and clear for days. It was eerie.
I was in the last generation who did not have to fear getting murdered at school. 1999 changed all of that, with the Columbine shooting. Nothing would be the same.
Green Day Comes to Their Own
Green Day, a punk rock trio comprised of front man Billie Joe Armstrong, bassist Mike Dirnt, and drummer Trés Cool, produced their breakout album, Dookie, in 1994. Hitting a more mainstream scene with “When I Come Around,” the band would score hits consistently for the next decade.
In 2004, I would graduate from high school and move on to a small women’s college. In September of that year, Green Day produced “American Idiot,” a surprising masterpiece of protest music from a band who, while quite well-known, were not known for the philosophical quality of their music. As a musician friend sneered, “Green Day is great at producing three-minute, upbeat songs.”
I’m not sure anyone was expecting the rock opera that was “American Idiot.” But when the title song gained airplay, there was a feeling of both surprise and validation.
The Dawning of a New Era
The first single off “American Idiot,” the eponymous song of the album, hits hard, offering catchy guitar riffs and lyrics that could be a campaign slogan, if your party was a bunch of punks.
The video depicts a very different image of the band. Heretofore, Green Day had been known for the visual distractions and shenanigans unfolding in their videos. Their previous album, “Warning” (2000), commercially tanked, compared to the prior success of its predecessor, “Nimrod” (1997).
In the videos from “Warning,” the trio continues their typical sophomoric hijinks, appearing to play in a kitchen as a man destroys every rule set before him in title track, playing in the midst of a destructive house party in “Waiting,” and riding on and dismembering a parade float in “Minority.”
But the visual aesthetic for “American Idiot” ushers in a new era for Green Day. The composition of the video is stark, introducing Armstrong in what can only be described as a sort of backwards Kraftwerk-style uniform, with added belt, jet-black hair, and black-as-your-soul eyeliner.
Unlike Green Day’s previous video output, “American Idiot” brutalizes through and because of its simplicity. The distressed, oversized American flag, the band clad in black as though mourning, the stark cinematography, and the encroaching sewage near the end drive home the point of a protagonist fed up with society, and the government at large.
The look was iconic. There is no other way to describe it. Never before or since has Green Day created and implemented such a systematic and defined aesthetic. Even the album cover, a pale hand clutching a bleeding, heart-shaped hand grenade against a black background, is in keeping with the band’s sartorial choices of that era.
While Green Day may not have invented the “guyliner“ and skinny tie look so emblematic of that era, there is no doubt that, with “American Idiot,” the band presented such a compelling aesthetic that many other bands of the early 2000s would go on to imitate.
American Anger
I remember how impressed I was with all of this. At 19, in my first year of college, I borrowed the album--a CD--from a friend, and I burned it onto my computer (hey, I, too, was punk!) so I could listen to it over and over. Being poor, CDs were hard to come by, and I had never owned a Green Day record, despite the fact that they were one of my earliest music influences.
By 2004, “Dubya“ was going up for reelection. The United States had inserted its military presence into two different countries. The war in Iraq would last for nearly a decade, the torture of the Abu Ghraib prisoners at the hands of American military coming to light in 2004, and the fallout from the ravages of invasion on the region untold. A war, according to the Pew Research Center, that 63% of Americans said was “not worth fighting.”
A war that 63% of Americans said was "not worth fighting."
Pew Research Center
In Afghanistan, Bush’s “War on Terrorism“ lasted 20 years. A triumphant military invaded a faraway nation, attempting to spread its democratic wings and rid the world of Osama bin Laden and his Al-Qaeda terrorist organization. By the 2020s, over 2,000 American military personnel alone had died, along with contractors, allies, and untold numbers of Afghan civilians. The quick escape out of Afghanistan after a two decade-long devastation of the region left only uncertainty and anxiety.
The protest of “American Idiot” in the wake of these world-changing events could not have come too soon. For me, this was a protest not of ideology, but a protest of survival. The saints of an “idiot” America became suburban wretches like the “Jesus of Suburbia,” and “Saint Jimmy,” people with low moral standards and even less ambition.
“American Idiot,” while catchy with hooks that could definitely lend the term “pop-punk“ to Green Day--if only because they are less abrasive and more universal to a larger audience--is a thoughtful album about shared trauma. A trauma and a frustration that many people at the threshold of adulthood shared as we watched helplessly.
We mourned with “Wake Me Up When September Ends,” an allusion to Armstrong’s father’s death when he was a child, but a song that could also easily refer to September 11 and the way it changed everyone’s worldview of combat, military, attacks, and terrorism. For my generation, in some respects, September would not end for years.
We identified with “Boulevard of Broken Dreams,” a song that skirts the maudlin, but so effectively captures the teenage alienation of that era, and the isolation of being an objector. It combats that John Donne adage that “no man is an island.” With the distorted guitar, hints of piano, and desolate lyrics, the song is an anthem of despair.
We commiserated with the trials and angst of “Jesus of Suburbia“ (beware, the video is full of triggering content), a teenage loser at the turn of the millennia, in an epic nine minute rock opera. Armstrong repeats in various ways, “I don’t care, I don’t care, I don’t care.” The almost violent malaise of not caring is central to the song’s mood. What can we, “the kids of war and peace,” do in the wake of so much trauma, unrest, and anger, with our mediocrity and powerlessness?
What can we, "the kids of war and peace," do in the wake of so much trauma, unrest, and anger, with our mediocrity and powerlessness?
We protested with “Holiday,” a song with influences in both punk and political rallies. The spoken word interruption near the end of the track, declared through a scratchy microphone, mocks “the president Gasman” while proclaiming a politics of peace in a way that doesn’t shy from emphasizing the dissatisfaction of ordinary people.
While the above tracks and their respective videos concisely illustrate the frustration and impotent rage of a generation with catchy and pop-like ease, “Give Me Novocain” and “Letterbomb” both paint pictures of an American landscape torn by politics, protest, and ennui. Not too different from today.
The George W. Bush era of politics and punishment, a traumatic time for young people who were coming of age, ushered in indisputably different ideologies and worldviews. The twin traumas of the Columbine massacre and the September 11 attacks would tattoo the hearts of millennials two decades later.
“The Jesus of Suburbia is a lie,” intimates Armstrong in “Are We the Waiting” near the middle of the album. While millennials perhaps didn’t do angst as well as Generation X, who had the full thrust of early punk, grunge, and industrial bands, protest music such as “American Idiot” was an essential part of our origin story.
American Fallout
Twenty years later, I remember the desire for numbness as well as the intense feeling of powerlessness. In the wake of the 24-hour news cycle, the increasing number of school shootings, and the vague War on Terrorism, what could I do? I chose to pursue philosophy at a sleepy liberal arts college, perhaps to medicate anxiety inspired by trauma, both personal and shared.
After the September 11 attacks, and after Dubya decided to declare war on Afghanistan and Iraq, I decided to stop standing up for every morning’s Pledge of Allegiance at my public high school. I sat down every time people stood, angry with the idea that I would be pledging to “One nation under God” when it clearly was not. It felt like its own kind of blasphemy, which I could not well articulate to the teacher who told me that I was blaspheming the lives of the servicemembers.
I recall one of my other teachers in political science suggesting that, if this teacher continued to harass me, we could get the ACLU involved. Luckily for me, she stopped the thrust of her harassment, but I did not stop sitting down. It was something that returned to my mind over 20 years later, when I looked over my life and my consistent desire to do the right thing in the wake of everyone else not caring.
Twenty years later, 'American Idiot' still inspires me, reminds me of a very sad time of change, but also fills me with hope.
Green Day articulated a generational sentiment at the time. While other bands, such as Nine Inch Nails, protested the Bush era through music, I can think of no other artist who so eloquently conveyed the zeitgeist of that era as thoroughly as Green Day. Twenty [two] years later, “American Idiot” still inspires me, reminds me of a very sad time of change, but also fills me with hope.
In the 2000s, I felt that claustrophobic despair, that inability to change my situation, the feeling of being so small compared to something so very, very powerful and widespread. Green Day both calmed and comforted me during these times. “American Idiot” perfectly articulated a pivotal part of my life, and on its 20th anniversary, I thank it.
I keep every post I make freely available because it’s important, but I enjoy the ability to eat and take care of my medical bills. If you appreciated this article, please promote my continued existence by considering a tip to Ko-Fi. Any amount is appreciated. Thank you!
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.