Learning How to Sell with Andy Rich

[Above: Video of Andy schooling me. And here is a folder that has AI-created scripts and two kinds of summaries of the show.]

🙏 Thank you to all our new paid subscribers! They and our sponsors help us do more—like this discussion with Andy Rich. The main newsletter will remain free, but our new virtual salon series will be for paid members. Here’s how you can support Sree’s Sunday Note, even if you can’t afford to pay.

💪 My Pre-diabetic Life: How I’m using some AI, some planning, some advice, and some luck to reverse a worrisome diagnosis. Powered by AROGYA WORLD, one of the most innovative health nonprofits in the world. Join our WhatsApp group and learn with me.

🎆 I am honored to be included in “250 at 250: The Indian American Story,” a list of 250 moments, 445 people, and 15 categories that shaped America. Curated by our friends at Indiaspora, which seeks “to inspire and position the Indian diaspora to be a force for good.”

Support us

ANDY RICH HAS FORGOTTEN MORE ABOUT SALES THAN I WILL EVER KNOW. So, I figured it would be good to talk to him, learn from him, and spread the word.

This is part of my new virtual salon series that focuses on people teaching me things. As I learn from them, you can too. As a perk for our paid members, we record these in Zoom so you can come and ask questions, salon-style (or just sit back and watch) and then a few days later, put the resulting video on YouTube and Substack and LinkedIn for everyone else.

[ If you’d like to nominate you or someone else teach me something, please do. And, yes, this is a poor man’s Pablo Torre Finds Out (which has broken global exclusives, won a Pulitzer Prize and is now distributed by the NYT’s The Athletic). ]

First of all, I am a self-diagnosed terrible salesman. I give away too much (ask any of my Digimentors colleagues), I constantly low-ball myself and what I can offer, and I lack the aggressiveness needed to really sell hard.

Second, the modern world is all sales. It’s a core skill set that goes well beyond the stereotypical salesperson. Universities and nonprofits—two industries I work with more than any other—often fail to understand this concept at a core level, and it hurts them with recruitment, fundraising, talent acquisition and more. Presenting a compelling argument for someone to choose you—a donor, a prospective student, faculty, senior leadership, and so on—all of this is sales.

Sales carries a negative reputation largely because most people’s exposure to it has been through unprofessional, pushy, or disrespectful salespeople. In our discussion, Andy drew a parallel to other professions: just as a bad experience with a doctor or lawyer is something you never forget, bad salespeople leave lasting negative impressions—and people encounter them far more frequently.

From the discussion:

Sree: You mentioned the “Scarlet S” — what do you mean by that?

Andy: People associate sales with cringy, high-pressure behavior—door-to-door salespeople, aggressive pitches. That image crushes people in business because if you’re not selling your ideas, your design, your vision—whether or not it’s on your business card—you have very little value. People need to get over it.

Sree: So even engineers and non-sales professionals need to sell?

Andy: Absolutely. If you’re an engineer, you’re selling your design, your technical judgment, your vision. You may not call it sales, but if you’re not doing it, you’re dead in the water.

One of Andy’s most crucial points was about the sales hero, and how the founder super-grind mentality tends to be ineffective over the long term. In essence, relying on one exceptional individual’s natural talent and energy cannot be scaled, taught, or replicated. Sure, born salespeople exist, but they typically cannot manage or train others because they lack a transferable process. From an investor’s perspective, a company built around one person’s heroism is a liability, not an asset. Investors want to see a repeatable system, not owner-dependent results.

Andy emphasized that, once a founder has even one other person on their team, they must shift from doing to leading, which requires a documented, teachable set of processes. Without it, CRM (customer relationship management) data becomes unreliable, revenue becomes unpredictable, and investor confidence erodes. Wall Street and small investors alike hate unpredictability.

The “cookbook” analogy is central here: if you know that 10 calls yield 3 appointments, and 3 appointments yield 1 presentation, and so on, you can predict outcomes and manage behavior accordingly. That is the foundation of a scalable sales operation.

From the discussion:

Sree: What does moving away from heroic selling mean for a small business owner or individual creator?

Andy: Heroes are great, but you can’t scale heroism. Once you have two people, you need to understand each other’s capabilities and build around a process. Investors don’t invest in heroes — they invest in CEOs who can build companies. If you can’t show a repeatable process, you won’t get capital.

Sree: Are there people who are naturally talented at sales?

Andy: Yes, but they often stink at managing salespeople because they can’t teach what they do instinctively. They’ll retire as the greatest salesperson in the world but never build a sales organization. Process is what makes leadership possible.

Know some who could be better at sales? Sure you do! Please hit forward now!

54% of 2026 is already over. What will you do with the remaining 46% of the year? LMK and I’ll see you made it all the way down here.

Share

OUR MOST RECENT ESSAYS: