Getting App Reviews Is Easy If You Ask at the Right Time

I was working with a startup that built their app around reviews.

The core experience was simple: test products, write reviews, post photos to social.
It started with beauty but expanded into other categories.

They had strong MAUs.
Products had hundreds, sometimes thousands, of reviews.
The community was active and vocal.

But the number of app store reviews stayed low, especially compared to how engaged people were in the app itself.

To change that, I built a simple plan.

We already knew people were leaving 4- and 5-star product reviews.
They were happy. They trusted the platform.
But no one thought to rate the app itself.

So I connected the dots and did two things:

• Added an app review prompt after someone left a positive product review

• Timed it while they were still in the app and still in a good mood

One week later:
→ App reviews increased by 166%
→ Installs rose by 33%

This isn’t just anecdotal. There’s a science to it.

Even happy users don’t think to leave app reviews because the default brain state is inertia.
Psychologists call it the intention-action gap.

BJ Fogg’s Behavior Model emphasizes that a well-timed prompt is often the difference between inaction and follow-through. When someone is already mentally engaged, the likelihood of action increases significantly.

Learn more

In other words, if someone just told you they loved a product, they’re far more likely to say yes to another request, like rating the app, right then and there.

This is also tied to a psychological principle known as affective carryover.
When people feel good in one context, that positivity can influence unrelated decisions.

Psychologist Norbert Schwarz has shown that positive emotions in one context can influence unrelated evaluations—a concept known as “affective carryover.”

Read More

That’s exactly what we tapped into.
We didn’t ask for an app review out of nowhere.
We asked when they were already feeling positive.

The common mistake is either:

• Not asking at all

• Asking at the wrong time (for example, when someone is in the middle of completing a task)

Timing matters more than frequency.
You only get a handful of chances before a user tunes you out or gets annoyed.

A better approach:

• Identify moments of delight (after positive reviews, successful purchases, good support interactions)

• Trigger review requests immediately afterward

• Make it seamless (in-app, friction-free, no redirect)

Nir Eyal’s work on habit formation highlights how timing can make or break a prompt. The same request might feel annoying or effortless depending on when it’s delivered.

Explore his work

There’s no media budget here. No giveaway.
Just smarter product timing.

And it worked:

• More app reviews → Better store visibility

• Better visibility → More installs

• More installs from high-intent users → Stronger conversion downstream

It’s not magic.
It’s just knowing when to ask.

If you want more reviews:

1. Find the moment users already feel positive

2. Ask for what you need, right then

Bonus if you do it in-app.
The fewer steps between prompt and publish, the higher the conversion.

Are you collecting reviews at the right moment?
Leave a comment, I’d love to hear what’s worked (or failed) for your team.