Why You Can’t Stop Thinking During Meditation (And Why That’s Not a Problem)

Constant mind wandering is completely normal. The biggest problem isn’t your racing thoughts — it’s how harshly you judge yourself when focus slips. Gentle redirection strengthens your meditation “muscle” with each practise.

Leave a comment

• A racing mind during meditation is normal and shows your awareness is active.

• Forcing focus can backfire due to the brain’s ironic processing response.

• Stress chemicals create brain-clouds that make concentration harder.

• The key skill in certain meditations is gently returning your focus.

• Self-compassion begins with allowing yourself to relax and rest.

Sally:

Hi, I’m your host, Sally, bringing you insights about meditation with Gordon from IntrAnaut Meditation Teacher College.

Have you ever sat down to meditate, hoping to find peace, but instead your mind starts racing with thoughts about dinner plans, work deadlines, or that awkward conversation from three years ago?

Gordon:

Oh, absolutely. You know, it’s fascinating that you bring this up because it’s actually the number one challenge people face when they try to meditate. I mean, we all go through it. That feeling of, why can’t I just quiet my mind?

Sally:

Right. It’s like the moment we try to find peace, ur brain decides it’s the perfect time to review our entire life story.

Gordon:

That’s exactly it. And you know what’s really interesting? This isn’t actually a sign that we’re failing at meditation. It’s completely normal. It’s just our brain doing what it’s designed to do.

Sally:

Hmm. Tell us more about that. Why does our brain seem to go into overdrive exactly when we’re trying to quiet it down?

Gordon:

Well, it’s actually due to something called the default mode network, or DMN. It’s basically our brain’s autopilot system that kicks in whenever we’re not focused on a specific task. Some people call it the monkey mind, and it’s literally built into our neural circuitry.

Sally:

That’s fascinating. So you’re saying we’re actually wired to have these wandering thoughts?

Gordon:

Exactly. And here’s where people often get tripped up. They try to fight against these thoughts, which usually makes things worse. ou know that thing where someone says, don’t think about a pink elephant?

Sally:

And then that’s all you can think about.

Gordon:

Precisely. It’s called ironic processing. The more you try to suppress thoughts, the more persistent they become. It’s like trying to relax by clenching your jaw. It just creates more tension.

Sally:

That makes a ton of sense. But what about people who deal with chronic anxiety? I imagine this must be particularly challenging for them.

Gordon:

You’ve hit on something really important there. For folks with chronic anxiety, the challenge is even more complex because of what’s happening in their brain chemistry. Stress chemicals actually create what we could call mental clouds that make it harder to focus.

Sally:

Oh, that’s interesting. So there’s actually a physiological component to this?

Gordon:

Absolutely. You know, it’s not just in your head. Well, I mean, it is. But these stress chemicals like cortisol and adrenaline literally create an environment in the brain that makes it harder to maintain focus and positive thoughts.

SPONSOR:

Struggling to find peace in meditation? Meet Colin Ellis, the teacher trainer at Intranaut Meditation Teacher College. With over three years in solitary meditation retreats and extensive training in Satori Enlightenment coaching, Colin understands the challenges of meditation.

Visit his Substack at MeditationTeacher.substack.com to learn how to transform your meditation practice with gentle, science-backed approaches that actually work.

Sally:

Thanks for that. So, coming back to our discussion, what’s the solution? How do we work with this wandering mind instead of fighting it?

Gordon:

The key is something that might seem counterintuitive at first, being gentle with yourself. Instead of criticising yourself when your mind wanders, you want to respond with kindness and self-compassion.

Sally:

But isn’t that easier said than done?

Gordon:

Oh, for sure. And you know what? That’s where many people get stuck. They hear, “be compassionate with yourself” and think it needs to be this big, dramatic shift. But really, it can start with something as simple as deciding to relax.

Sally:

Could you break that down for us? What does that actually look like in practice?

Gordon:

Consider how you would treat a friend in crisis. You wouldn’t criticise them, right? You’d be supportive and understanding. This involves creating what I refer to as an energetic environment where rest and time out are available.

Sally:

I love that analogy. It makes self-compassion feel more accessible.

Gordon:

Right, and here’s a simple three-step technique anyone can use.

1. First, acknowledge that your mind has wandered. Just a simple “thinking” label.

2. Second, release the thought without analysing it.

3. And third, gently return your focus to your breath or whatever your anchor is.

Sally:

Is it like mental reps for your attention instead of fitness reps at the gym?

Gordon:

That’s exactly what it is. Each time you notice your mind wandering and gently bring it back, you’re actually strengthening your meditation muscle. The focus isn’t on having zero thoughts. It’s on how you respond when they show up.

Sally:

This feels like such a different approach from what many people think meditation should be.

Gordon:

Yeah, we’ve gotten this idea that meditation means having a completely quiet mind. But that’s like saying exercise only counts if you never get tired. The work is in the coming back, in the gentle return.

Sally:

You mentioned earlier about stress creating mental clouds. Can you elaborate on that?

Gordon:

Sure? Um, imagine your brain as a clear blue sky. When you experience stress, these chemicals create what’s like dark clouds, making it harder to think clearly. Everyone’s clouds are different. Some might be small and passing, others might be larger and more persistent.

Sally:

And I imagine fighting against these clouds only makes them darker.

Gordon:

Exactly. When we’re harsh with ourselves, we actually trigger more stress responses, which creates more clouds, which leads to more distraction. It’s a cycle that feeds itself.

Sally:

So what’s the first step for someone who wants to break this cycle?

Gordon:

Start with gentle relaxation. You don’t have to jump straight to loving yourself or having some profound spiritual experience. Just decide to relax for a moment. Relax away from the distorted thinking. It’s like opening a door to better meditation.

Sally:

That feels doable, much more approachable than trying to force our minds to be quiet.

Gordon:

And you know what’s really cool? Each time you make that choice to be gentle, you’re actually changing your brain chemistry. You’re releasing calming chemicals like oxytocin and endorphins instead of stress hormones.

Sally:

For our listeners who might be feeling overwhelmed right now, what’s one simple thing they can try today?

Gordon:

Here’s a quick 30-second reset. Place your hand on your heart. Take three deep breaths and simply say to yourself, “My mind is doing what minds do. This is normal. I choose to be gentle with myself right now.”

Sally:

That’s beautiful in its simplicity. Any final thoughts for our listeners?

Gordon:

Remember, you’re not failing at meditation when your mind wanders. You’re actually doing it right. Every time you notice and gently return, that’s meditation. That’s the practice. You’re not fixing your mind. You’re befriending it.

Sally:

Thank you so much for sharing these insights with us today. This has been incredibly helpful.

Gordon:

Thank you for having me. And remember, meditation involves meeting distraction with gentleness, one moment at a time.