Schism & Culture War: Understanding the SSPX Split

Dear Listeners,

This week on Whiplash, Emma and I are unpacking one of the biggest Catholic news stories of the year: the Vatican’s declaration that the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) is in schism.

Almost immediately, the announcement sparked a familiar cycle online. Memes spread across Catholic social media. People began asking why the SSPX had been declared schismatic while other figures they disagreed with had not. Before long, the conversation had become another front in the Catholic culture war.

In this episode, we argue that those reactions reveal something important. Rather than asking how the Church itself understands schism, many people instinctively interpret events through political narratives about winners and losers, heroes and villains, or whose side the Vatican is supposedly taking. Those narratives can make for compelling social media posts, but they often obscure the theological, historical, and canonical questions that are actually at the heart of the story.

Emma shares how the SSPX developed, why Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre’s movement became increasingly separated from Rome, and what ultimately led to this moment. Along the way, we discuss the movement’s political history, its relationship to broader traditionalist and far-right currents, and why understanding that history matters if we want to make sense of the present.

The episode also explores a broader question: what happens when our understanding of the Church becomes shaped primarily by culture-war thinking? Once every controversy is reduced to a battle between ideological camps, it becomes much harder to recognize the distinctions the Church itself is trying to make. The result is a conversation driven more by outrage and comparison than by careful attention to history, theology, or canon law.

If this topic sounds familiar, it’s because Emma and I have written about the SSPX before. In June 2025, as part of our High Control Catholicism series, we examined the Society’s history and its community in St. Marys, Kansas, exploring how separatist religious environments can shape identity, authority, and daily life. If you’d like additional historical context alongside this week’s episode, I encourage you to revisit that article as well:

As always, thank you for listening, sharing the show, and supporting this work. Your support makes conversations like these possible.

Peace,
Max

🎧 Listen to the podcast here on Substack (where you can toggle between video with subtitles and just the audio file, and read a transcript by clicking the button on the top of the episode page on the web), Spotify (which has video and in-app transcripts), Apple Podcasts (which has in-app transcripts), and YouTube.