It begins with cheap beer, bad decisions, and the kind of night you never forget. Not for the reason you think.
Please free to share your thoughts in the comments below! I look forward to reading them! And don’t forget to subscribe so you never miss a post!
To celebrate my 1 year anniversary on Substack, I am offering a huge discount. I’m updating all of my work and removing paid posts. However, paid subs get access to my sub chat. You can drop links, memes, jokes, thoughts. Promote yourself. Promote someone else.
Your support means so much to me. Thank you! Not to brag, but I think you guys are the greatest subscribers on Substack.
The party happened during my junior year, in a house nobody actually lived in.
People slept there, received mail there, occasionally heated food there, but calling it a home would have insulted every house with a working smoke detector. It belonged to four guys from our floor who had pooled their parents’ money and rented the cheapest place they could find near campus. The porch leaned left. The kitchen leaned right. The entire structure seemed to be attempting to lie down.
Every Friday, we helped it.
That night was supposed to celebrate something. A birthday, maybe. Midterms ending. One of the roommates getting his driver’s license reinstated. I have heard several versions over the years, and each one sounds possible.
Back then, we did not need much of a reason.
Someone had dragged two stereo speakers into the living room and placed them on milk crates. The music was loud enough to turn conversation into amateur lip-reading. A strand of Christmas lights had been stapled around the ceiling although it was September. Red cups covered every flat surface. The floor stuck to our shoes with such determination that walking across the room required actual effort.
I remember thinking it was the best party I had ever attended.
We arrived around ten, already half drunk because Noah had made us drink in the parking lot.
Noah believed entering a party sober was disrespectful to the host.
“You don’t show up at a funeral alive,” he said.
“That’s exactly how you show up at a funeral,” I told him.
He pointed at me with his beer.
“This is why nobody lets you make speeches.”
Noah had been my friend since freshman orientation. He was the first person I met who seemed completely comfortable anywhere. He could walk into a room where he knew nobody and, ten minutes later, be borrowing somebody’s car. He had an average face, brown hair, narrow eyes, nothing remarkable, but people liked him because he behaved as though they already did.
We had met while standing in line to get our student identification cards. The machine broke immediately before my turn.
Noah looked at me and said, “You’ve been rejected by college.”
I laughed harder than the joke deserved.
That was enough to begin a friendship then.
The third guy with us was Martin, who spent the first hour of the party trying to convince a woman named Elise that he played bass guitar.
He did not.
She asked what band he was in.
Martin looked at me for help.
“The divorced fathers,” I said.
Elise laughed. Martin told her we were between drummers.
Later, I found him in the kitchen holding a can opener and pretending he knew how to use it on a bottle of wine.
That was the kind of night it was at first.
The house was crammed with students from different parts of campus. Football players drank with theater majors. Two women from the nursing program were doing shots beside a philosophy student who kept announcing that free will was an illusion before choosing to drink again.
A guy named Travis had removed his shirt for no identifiable reason. He had written PROPERTY OF THE STATE across his chest in black marker. Nobody knew what it meant, including Travis.
In the living room, people danced because there was nowhere else to stand. Every few minutes, the music stopped when someone kicked the power strip loose. Then thirty people shouted at once until the music returned.
I remember a woman in a green dress grabbing my hands and pulling me into the crowd.
I asked her name.
She shouted something.
“What?”
She shouted again.
I nodded like I had heard her.
For twenty minutes I called her Natalie.
Her name was Catherine.
She corrected me several times and eventually decided Natalie was funny enough to keep.
I told her my name was Patrick.
It is not.
There was a freedom to being that age and drunk among strangers. You could become briefly interesting. You could lie about your name, your major, your confidence. You could dance badly and call it irony. Every foolish thing seemed temporary because morning had not happened yet.
Noah appeared beside us wearing a cowboy hat he had stolen from somewhere inside the house.
“My father wants me home by eleven,” he said.
It was nearly midnight.
“Your father lives in Arizona,” I said.
“He is very strict.”
He put the hat on Catherine’s head, kissed her hand and disappeared into the kitchen.
I remember watching him go.
I remember smiling.
The night broke apart into bright little pieces after that.
Martin vomiting into a laundry basket because he thought it was a trash can.
Someone trying to cook frozen chicken nuggets directly on the oven rack.
Two guys wrestling in the yard, stopping midway through because one had lost his wallet, then searching together on their hands and knees.
A woman sitting on the porch giving serious relationship advice to a plastic skeleton left over from Halloween.
Around one in the morning, I joined a drinking game I did not understand. The rules appeared to change whenever I began winning. At some point, I drank something blue from a glass jar. Nobody could tell me what was in it.
A chemistry student said, “You’re probably fine.”
Then he walked away.
Twenty minutes later, the urgent need to piss arrived.
There was no warning. One moment, I was leaning against a wall listening to Martin explain why raccoons would make good police officers. The next, my bladder seemed prepared to resign from my body.
I pushed through the living room toward the downstairs bathroom.
It was down a narrow hallway near the kitchen. Five or six people stood there talking. A couple leaned against the wall, kissing with the grim concentration of people trying to pass an exam. Two women were sharing a cigarette under an open window. A guy in a red sweatshirt sat on the floor holding a bag of ice against his forehead.
I tried the bathroom door.
Locked.
I knocked.
“Occupied,” someone yelled.
“I’m dying.”
“Die somewhere else.”
The guy on the floor pointed upstairs with the bag of ice.
“There’s another bathroom.”
“Where?”
“Upstairs.”
“I understand the concept. Which door?”
He considered this.
“One of them.”
A woman by the window said, “End of the hall, I think.”
Her friend shook her head. “No, that’s a bedroom.”
“Bathrooms are basically bedrooms with plumbing.”
I should have gone outside.
There were bushes along the fence. Half the men at the party had already used them. I could have walked into the yard, pissed against the siding, returned to Catherine or Natalie or whatever name we had decided she had, and carried the night with me as another stupid college story.
Instead, I went upstairs.
The staircase was steep and carpeted in brown material that might once have been beige. Empty bottles lined the steps. The music grew duller as I climbed, each beat traveling through the walls instead of the air.
At the top was a dark hallway with four closed doors.
No signs. No light under any of them.
I tried the first door on the left.
It opened three inches before hitting something.
A woman laughed from inside.
I pushed harder against the door, the cheap wood groaning as it swung inward.
There they were.
A shirtless guy with a soft belly and jeans unbuttoned was leaning against a cheap laminate dresser, his hand wrapped around a half empty bottle of whiskey. On the bed, a woman with bleached hair was on all knees, her back arched, a thin sheet tangled around one leg. Behind her, another man, fully clothed in a black t shirt, had his hands gripping her hips, his expression one of intense concentration. All three heads snapped toward me at the exact same moment, their faces tightening from pleasure and focus into a mask of pure annoyance.
The shirtless guy, the one against the dresser, was the first to speak. He took a slow swig from the bottle before letting out an exasperated, “Dude.”
My eyes darted around the room, anywhere but at them. “Bathroom?” I managed, my voice cracking slightly.
He just shook his head once, a sharp, definitive gesture. “No.”
“Sorry,” I mumbled, already backing away.
I pulled the door closed, but not before I heard the woman let out an impatient sigh. The click of the latch echoed in the hallway, followed immediately by the rhythmic, creaking sound of the bed frame starting up again from behind the thin wood.For several years afterward, that was the part of the story I told.
I told people about opening the wrong door and finding three strangers arranged in a way that required athletic commitment. I improved the details over time. In some versions, one of them offered me a drink. In another, I asked whether they had seen my jacket.
People laughed.
I always stopped there.
The second door opened onto a closet filled with coats and cleaning supplies. A vacuum tipped forward and struck me in the shin.
I whispered several words that would have disappointed my mother.
Then I tried the door across the hall.
It opened easily.
The room beyond was dark except for a desk lamp on the floor.
At first I could not understand what I was looking at.
I saw a bed.
A woman’s bare leg hung over the side. Her foot was inches above the carpet. One black shoe remained strapped around her ankle. The other lay near the doorway.
A man stood between her knees.
His jeans were down.
His shirt was still on.
He turned.
It was Noah.
The music downstairs struck through the floor beneath us. A bass line. People shouting. Somebody laughing hard enough to cough.
Noah stared at me.
I stared at the woman.
She was on her back. Her dress had been pushed above her waist. Her arms rested beside her head with the palms open. Her face had fallen toward the wall. Her mouth was parted.
She was not moving.
Noah pulled away from her.
“What the fuck are you doing?” I said.
He yanked his jeans up.
“Shut the door.”
I didnt.
He crossed the room in two steps, grabbed the front of my shirt and pulled me inside. The door slammed behind me.
“What the fuck is wrong with you?” he said.
I can still remember his breath.
Beer and mint gum.
He always chewed gum when he drank because he thought it fooled people.
I looked at the woman again.
There was vomit dried near the corner of her mouth. A red plastic cup lay on its side beneath the bed. Her chest moved, although I had to watch for several seconds before I saw it.
“She’s unconscious,” I said.
“She’s drunk.”
“She’s unconscious.”
“No shit, she’s drunk.”
He spoke to me as though I were being difficult.
As though I had interrupted him while he was changing a tire.
I stepped toward the bed.
Noah blocked me.
“What did you give her?”
“Nothing.”
“What did you give her?”
“Nothing. She drank too much.”
I said her name.
I did not know her name.
I said, “Hey.”
She did not move.
I touched her shoulder.
Noah slapped my hand away.
“Don’t.”
That word cleared something inside me.
The room became exact.
The chipped paint around the window.
The dark stain on the carpet.
The desk lamp lying sideways, its shade removed.
Noah’s belt hanging open.
The woman’s heel suspended above the floor.
I could see every part of it, and none of it seemed real. “We need to get somebody,” I said.
“No.”
“We need to call an ambulance.”
“She doesn’t need an ambulance.”
“She doesn’t know where she is.”
“She knew where she was earlier.”
I looked at him.
He looked back.
There was no panic in his face anymore.
Only calculation.
He had already moved on from being caught. Now he was deciding what to do with me.
“I’m getting someone,” I said.
I reached for the door.
He grabbed my wrist.
“Think about this.”
“Let go of me.”
“You think about what you’re doing.”
“I know what you’re doing.”
“You don’t know shit.”
“She can’t even open her eyes.”
“She wanted it.”
“She’s passed out.”
“She wasn’t when we came up here.”
I pulled my arm free.
Noah stepped between me and the door.
For a moment I thought he might hit me.
Part of me wanted him to.
A punch would have simplified the room. It would have made him completely separate from me. A monster. An attacker. Something I could fight without examining where I had been standing all these years.
Instead, he lowered his voice.
“You want to ruin your life over this?”
“My life?”
“You think they’re going to believe you were just walking around looking for a bathroom?”
“What are you talking about?”
He watched my face.
Then he said, “What about the chemistry test?”
I said nothing.
The music continued downstairs.
The woman breathed behind us.
Noah smiled without showing his teeth.
“Who stole the answer key?” he asked.
“That has nothing to do with this.”
“Who emailed it to everyone?”
“Shut up.”
“And the Hartwell game?”
My stomach tightened.
Hartwell was our rival college. Two months earlier, before the basketball tournament, someone had broken into their athletic building. The court had been covered in motor oil. Lockers were filled with rotten fish. Their mascot, a live white pigeon named Victory, had been found dead in the training pool.
The newspaper called it an act of criminal vandalism.
Noah and I called it the funniest night of our lives.
We had been drunk.
That was the excuse we used among ourselves.
I had poured the oil.
I had opened the cage.
I had not drowned the bird, but I had left the pool room when Noah started laughing and chasing it with a broom. When I returned, it was floating near the drain.
“I didn’t kill that bird,” I said.
“You were there.”
“So were you.”
“Sure. And I’ll tell them everything. The test answers. The gym.”
“You’d go down too.”
He shrugged.
“Maybe.”
The shrug frightened me more than anything else he had done.
It told me he understood the gamble.
He knew the person with more to lose was not necessarily the person facing the worse accusation. It was the person more afraid of being known.
I had a scholarship.
My mother had taken a second job to pay what the scholarship did not cover. My father told everyone at his factory that his son would be the first person in the family to graduate from college. I had spent my whole life being described as the good one.
I looked at the woman.
She made a small sound.
A breath catching in her throat.
I wish I could tell you that sound saved her.
I wish I could tell you it saved me.
Noah leaned close.
“Nothing happened,” he said. “You opened the door. She was passed out. I was trying to help her.”
“Your pants were down.”
“You were drunk.”
“I saw you.”
“You saw what you think you saw.”
I remember my hand on the doorknob.
I remember believing that one movement would divide my life into before and after.
I remember letting go.
Noah studied me for a moment.
Then he fixed his belt.
“Go downstairs,” he said.
I went.
I found the downstairs bathroom empty.
I pissed for what felt like five minutes.
My hands shook against the wall.
When I returned to the party, the music seemed louder. Catherine saw me and smiled. She was still wearing Noah’s stolen cowboy hat.
“Patrick,” she shouted.
I stared at her.
She laughed because she thought I was drunk.
I was.
I drank until I could no longer picture the bedroom clearly.
By morning, I had convinced myself Noah would take care of it. He would wake the woman. He would apologize. Maybe I had misunderstood. Maybe there was a conversation before I entered. Maybe she had consented earlier. Maybe unconsciousness did not erase something already agreed to.
The mind will build shelter from any material it is given.
Even garbage.
Her name was Emily Jones.
I learned that three days later when campus security asked whether anyone had seen her at the party. She had awakened in the room alone, bleeding and confused. She remembered drinking with friends. She rememberedsomeone bringing her water. She remembered the stairs.
Nothing after that.
I said I had not seen her.
Noah said the same.
No charges were filed.
There was not enough evidence. There were too many people. Too much alcohol. Too many missing hours.
Emily withdrew before the semester ended.
In February, she killed herself in her parents’ garage.
I found out through a campus email.
The message did not mention the party.
It described her as a gifted student, a beloved daughter and an active member of the volunteer association. Counseling services were available to anyone affected by the tragedy.
I deleted the email.
Then I emptied the trash folder because seeing her name there felt dangerous.
That was more than twenty years ago.
Noah lives in North Carolina now.
His wife is a dentist. They have three children. The oldest plays Softball. The youngest recently learned to swim.
I know this because we are friends on social media.
That sentence is worse than the first one.
Every December, his family poses in matching pajamas beside a fireplace. He posts photographs from beach vacations. His wife writes paragraphs about how grateful she is to have married her best friend.
People comment that he is a good man.
Sometimes Noah likes their comments.
Once a year, on my birthday, he sends me a message.
Hope you’re doing well, brother.
I never respond.
I never block him either.
I look at his life because I want to find damage.
A crack in the marriage. An arrest. A child who refuses to speak to him. Some public misery large enough to suggest that the world noticed what I refused to report.
There is never anything.
Only birthday cakes.
School pictures.
A new deck behind the house.
His daughters sitting on his shoulders at a parade.
Last month, he posted a photograph from his oldest child’s graduation.
He stood beside his wife with one arm around her waist. He had gained weight. His hair had gone gray at the temples. He looked ordinary. Proud. Safe.
The caption said he could not believe how quickly time had passed.
I thought about the upstairs hallway.
The wrong door.
The closet.
The desk lamp on the floor.
Emily’s shoe near the bed.
I thought about all the years between that room and his smiling family.
Then I thought about the months Emily got.
Four of them.
Four months while we finished classes, attended parties, complained about assignments, planned our futures.
Four months while Noah laughed.
Four months while I said nothing.
People tell stories about college because they enjoy meeting the person they used to be. The reckless person. The drunk person. The person who made mistakes before adulthood arrived and explained the consequences.
I used to tell mine that way.
The collapsing porch. The blue drink. Martin and his imaginary band. Catherine calling me Patrick.
Everyone laughed.
I laughed too.
Now, as I write this, a gun sitting beside me on the bed, one bullet, I understand that the funniest night of my life and the worst thing I ever did happened in the same house.
They happened minutes apart.
Downstairs, thirty people danced beneath Christmas lights.
Upstairs, a woman lay unconscious.
And I found the bathroom.
That is what I did.
I found it.
Then I went back to the party.
Thank you so much for reading! I know it’s cliche to say, but I appreciate it from the bottom of my heart. If you enjoyed my latest poem, please check out more of my work. See below!
My poetry collection, Paper Blanket: Collected Poems is available on Amazon in Ebook, Paperback, and Hardcover editions. Order your copy now:
Paper Blanket: Collected Poems
My horror collection, The Face in the Dark, is now available in ebook and paperback editions. Order your copy now!
If you would like to help a struggling buy a coffee, please consider becoming a paid subscriber ($8/month, $80/annual) on Substack or leaving me a donation in the link below. Thank you all so much for your support!
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.