When picking music for digital content, most brand execs, social media managers, and content producers chase numbers. Streams, followers, monthly listeners… the bigger, the better, right? It looks impressive, feels safe, and it’s easy to brag about. Can’t go wrong.
Well… yes, but also no. Chasing raw popularity can miss the most important piece, fan engagement. Are the fans of this artist actually going to care if they see your brand using music they like? Or are you just buying a familiar name, hoping for safety, or worse, picking a stock track that connects with no one?
If you know Moneyball, you’ll recognize the parallel: inefficiency often comes from measuring the wrong thing, or nothing at all. Billy Beane didn’t just look at runs or batting averages; he analyzed stats to find hidden value. Brands can do the same with music, focus on engagement, not vanity metrics, because connecting emotionally sells. And music fandom is emotional.
Here’s our hypothesis: the smaller the fanbase, the bigger the punch.
On a flight home to LA from Munich this year, I watched Becoming Led Zeppelin, the new documentary about the band’s early rise. Robert Plant said something that stuck:
“Think about it, we were 20 years old […] and so many characters that suddenly arrive on the scene, this huge sort of sub-sub culture that spins around fame, especially fame in its very early stages cause that’s the place where you can smell something new coming.”
Early fame hits different. Early fanbases are engaged. They’re flush with musicheads, people obsessed with discovering new sounds, obsessively sharing, promoting, discussing, defending the music they love.
You know the type: fans who comb obscure playlists, hunt venue listings, or in the ’90s, made mixtapes for friends just because. They’re not passive. They care, they act, they spread culture.
“Research shows that passionate music fans who internalize music as part of their identity are more emotionally engaged and more likely to share and socialize around it, supporting the idea that early fans drive organic cultural spread.” (Read “Passion, music, and psychological well-being”)
Not surprisingly, early fans often have outgoing personalities and high social engagement. They’re the ones who carry artists forward, online and offline. For brands, these are the fans you want to reach, your vectors for organic engagement, the rare, precious currency that drives cultural impact and viral wins.
Emerging fanbases—indie artists with tens of thousands of passionate, dedicated fans rather than millions of passive listeners—deliver cost-effective impact. They’re hyper-engaged, tightly connected, and often hyperlocal. They actively share, discuss, and defend music, giving brands a chance to resonate deeply.
Contrast that with massive fanbases: millions of listeners, but lower engagement per fan. You get reach, sure, but you lose resonance. Fans become passive, distant, harder to move, and harder to convert into meaningful engagement.
Sarita M. Stewart’s Artist–Fan Engagement Model supports this: as fanbases expand, maintaining strong parasocial relationships becomes harder. Those parasocial ties are crucial for deep engagement, and as the audience grows, intimacy and impact naturally dilute. (Read “The development of the artist-fan engagement model”)
Brands chasing big numbers often miss the real ROI. Authentic connection drives engagement, cultural relevance, and impact. Small, engaged fanbases let you:
Test ideas quickly and cheaply
Connect with audiences who genuinely care about the music and the message
Shape music culture by partnering with artists who are culturally relevant, not just popular
Licensing music from emerging artists is more than a feel-good move, it’s smart business when done strategically. In a world drowning in AI slop and stock tracks, it’s frankly not surprising engagement rates are falling across platforms. And that’s precisely why real music that’s recognizable, loved and shared by fans can cut through the noise and deliver that spark.⚡️
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.