A coach I talked to this week has a great framework. Four pillars. One extra principle. Weekly newsletter that rotates through them.
Which sounds smart.
It’s the kind of thing a writing coach would compliment. It’s the kind of thing I probably would’ve complimented five years ago.
But when I asked him how his newsletter was converting, the answer was the same one I hear a lot.
“Good opens. Low conversions.”
Here’s the problem I’ve watched a lot of creators fall into, and it took me a while to see it.
He’s not writing a newsletter.
He’s writing a book... one chapter at a time... and calling it a newsletter.
His readers are getting educated.
They’re getting organized.
They’re getting a tidy table of contents delivered to their inbox every Monday.
What they’re not getting is invited to do anything.
No small hook that points to one offer.
No specific moment that reminds them why they subscribed in the first place.
No story that makes them feel like the advice was written for them, not for chapter 3 of a hardcover.
Book writing and email writing are different skills.
Books teach. Emails sell.
Books cover. Emails converge.
Books organize. Emails ask.
If you want a book someday, write one.
If you want a newsletter that pays you, write that.
Matt “chapters are for chapters” Ragland
P.S. If your newsletters are ending up more like drafts of chapters than actual emails — the fix is usually structural. Comment STYLES and I’ll send you the one-page cheat sheet with the 4 email structures I use most.
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.