The ancient Greeks were quite concerned about justice in the polis, the city state. Justice was one of the essential Cardinal virtues (justice, wisdom, temperance, courage) that governed the activity of the soul, establishing the conditions to the mutual flourishing all citizens in society. Justice was a quintessential goal of all human activity, making the telos of eudaimonia, human happiness and flourishing a possible reality. Thomas Aquinas, who essentially “baptized” Aristotle’s virtue ethics model, provides a critical understanding of justice needed into today’s fractured and divided society.
For Aquinas, the virtue of justice is chiefly concerned with the governance of human relationships and the mutual flourishing of all in society. Principally, it is committed to providing each individual what they deserve in society[1]. This involves a serious deontological commitment to the welfare of others. Moreover, legal justice is principally concerned with governing human behavior as it relates to the common good of the community[2]. The virtue of justice does not focus on individual benefits but the welfare of the community. According to Aquinas, individuals in a community are essential parts of a whole. Therefore, matters that affect one part of the community, affect the whole. Things that are good or harmful for individuals are good or harmful for the whole community. Thus, community leaders should create laws that govern society in a manner that benefits the whole.
For Aquinas, the quintessential reason for justice in society is to work toward the common good of all people. The non- renewal of vital health care subsidies, while providing unprecedented tax breaks to millionaire and billionaires, has made health insurance unaffordable for millions. This does not support the common good of all citizens. New work requirements and eligibility checks, that make it more difficult for vulnerable citizens to have Medicaid coverage do not support the common good of citizens. Policies that put caps on student loans for those seeking careers in nursing and healing professions do not support the common good.
In a society, plagued with division and partisan politics, we could benefit from a deeper understanding of what it means to embrace the common good, to work toward not only our own wellbeing , but the flourishing all in society. The ancient Greeks understood something vital about the activity of the soul and the activities that lead to the common good of all. Unfortunately, this wisdom is quickly vanishing from our modern view of the world. It is a understanding we cannot afford to lose. Indeed, the prophetic witness of the scriptures still echoes through the airy stream:
He has told you, mortal one, what is good;
And what does the Lord require of you
But to do justice, to love [a]kindness,
And to walk [b]humbly with your God?(Micah 6:8)
So, let us go forth during these challenging times, working toward justice and the common good of all in society. For then we shall please the Triune God of creation and work towards the flourishing of all.
Donald E. Williams is a United Methodist pastor and Duke University graduate. He completed his doctorate at Duke University in 2022 and is the author of numerous books to include An Investigation Into the Relationship Between Aristotelian Eudaimonia and Christian Discipleship: A Thomistic Perspective, Wipf and Stock Publishers.
Website: http://www.virtuespromise.com
[1] “Thomas Aquinas” Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://iep.utm.edu/thomas-aquinas/accessed 4/15/22
[2] Ibid
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.