Ya asked for a part two — so here we are.
If you missed part one, the concept is simple: dessert does not have to work against your goals. It just has to be built smarter. No refined sugar, real ingredients, and enough protein that the thing you are eating at the end of the day is actually contributing something to your nutrition rather than just existing in your calorie budget.
These five are from my Substack archives — all of them recipes I have made and eaten myself, all of them genuinely satisfying in the way that only real dessert can be. Click through to any of the full recipes for complete ingredients, instructions, and my notes on each one.
Let’s get into it.
1. 5-Ingredient Flourless Banana Protein Cookies
Per cookie (1 of 12) — Calories: 110 | Protein: 6.4g | Carbs: 8.4g | Fat: 6.7g | Fiber: 2.1g
Sweetened with: ripe banana + Lily’s sugar-free dark chocolate chips
Five ingredients. No flour. No refined sugar. Sweetened entirely by overripe banana and Lily’s stevia-sweetened chocolate chips — which means you get all the chocolate chip cookie experience with none of the blood sugar spike that comes with traditional cookie recipes. The protein comes from peanut butter and protein powder which both disappear completely into the texture, leaving you with something that genuinely reads as a cookie rather than a health food approximation of one.
Make twelve of these on a Sunday and you have dessert covered all week at under 115 calories and over 6 grams of protein per cookie.
2. 2-Minute Chocolate Protein Mug Cake
Serves 1 — Calories: 176 | Protein: 13.3g | Carbs: 25.2g | Fat: 6g | Fiber: 5.9g
Sweetened with: Lily’s sugar-free dark chocolate chips — no added sugar in the batter
The one I have made almost every single night for a year and a half. Two minutes from ingredients to spoon, no refined sugar anywhere in the recipe, and nearly 14 grams of protein in something that tastes like a warm, fudgy chocolate cake. The fiber number — almost 6 grams — is exceptional for a dessert this size and mostly comes from the Lily’s chips which use chicory root fiber as a sugar replacement.
If you only make one recipe from this list, make this one. It will become a nightly habit faster than you expect.
3. 3-Ingredient Protein Chocolate Chip Cookies
Per cookie (1 of 12 mini) — Calories: 110 | Protein: 7g | Carbs: 10g | Fat: 4g | Fiber: ~2g
Sweetened with: ripe banana + 2 tbsp honey across the full batch (minimal per cookie)
Three ingredients plus chocolate chips — banana, peanut butter, and protein powder — come together into a mini cookie that is dense, slightly chewy, peanut buttery, and finished with a scatter of chocolate chips and flaky sea salt on top. The honey in the recipe is two tablespoons across twelve cookies which works out to an almost negligible amount per serving — enough to give the cookies a little natural sweetness without crossing into refined sugar territory.
These are Blakely approved which is the highest quality rating available in our household.
4. Gluten Free Cinnamon Sugar Donut Holes
Per donut hole (1 of 8) — Calories: 78 | Protein: 3.5g | Carbs: 13g | Fat: 1g
Full batch — Calories: 620 | Protein: 28g
Sweetened with: monk fruit sweetener + cinnamon topping — zero refined sugar
These are the recipe that hit pure nostalgia for me — warm, cinnamon-sugared donut holes that taste like a weekend treat and happen to be made from cottage cheese, gluten free flour, and an egg. The cinnamon sugar coating uses monk fruit sweetener instead of regular sugar which means the whole thing stays refined sugar free while still delivering that satisfying sugary crunch on the outside.
At 78 calories per hole you can eat three or four of them and still be well within a reasonable dessert. The full batch delivers 28 grams of protein — genuinely remarkable for what is essentially a donut.
5. 3-Ingredient Blender Protein Crepes With Berries
Per crepe (1 of 4) — Calories: 106 | Protein: 8.7g | Carbs: 6.7g | Fat: 4.8g | Fiber: 0.7g
Full serving with Greek yogurt filling — Protein: ~50g
Sweetened with: fresh fruit topping only — zero added sugar in the base
Yes — crepes as dessert. Hear me out.
Three ingredients blended smooth and cooked thin — cottage cheese, egg, and a touch of flour — into a pliable, slightly golden crepe that is genuinely versatile enough to go savory at lunch and sweet at dessert. Fill them with Greek yogurt and fresh berries, a drizzle of honey, sliced banana and PBfit, or whatever fruit you have on hand. The base itself has no added sugar whatsoever — any sweetness comes entirely from whatever you put inside.
Four crepes with a Greek yogurt filling gets you close to 50 grams of protein. As a dessert situation with berries and a small drizzle of honey it is light, satisfying, and genuinely feels like something you would order at a restaurant.
Five more reasons to stop treating dessert like the enemy.
It was never the dessert. It was the ingredients inside it. Swap refined sugar for natural sweeteners, build in some protein, use real whole food ingredients — and suddenly dessert is something your body can actually work with instead of against.
If you want even more recipes built around this same approach my free macro-balanced recipe e-book has a full collection waiting for you.
Want a part three? Like this post to let me know!
Xx
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.