Reading · Adrian Fleming · RSS Amplifier

This page did not load. You can still read it on the original site — the toolbar below keeps your place in the directory.

You won't be failing. You'll just be permanently smaller than you should be, and celebrating it annually.

“Better than last year” only measures you against your past self. That is a low bar.

You grew fifteen per cent and everyone relaxed. Nobody asked whether it should have been thirty.

A good number arrives. Revenue up fifteen per cent on last year. The best quarter the business has had. Growth, real and measurable, on the page. And the room does what rooms do with a good number. It relaxes. The number becomes proof that things are working, and proof, of any kind, is the end of inquiry.

That moment of relaxation is one of the most expensive things that happens in a business, and almost nobody notices it happening. Because the number going up is not the same as the business doing as well as it could have. And the comfortable thing about a number going up is that it stops anyone asking the difference.

GROWTH ENDS THE CONVERSATION

Watch what a good result does to a meeting. The figure goes up, there is a small, genuine wave of relief, and the discussion moves on. Maybe a round of credit. Then the next agenda item.

The number has done its work. It has answered the question “are we doing well” with a yes, and a yes closes the file. Nobody interrogates a yes. You interrogate problems, not wins.

A bad number would have triggered an hour of hard questions. The good number triggered a nod. And so the single best opportunity to ask whether the business is really performing, a moment when there is data, attention and goodwill in the room, gets spent on relief instead.

“BETTER THAN LAST YEAR” IS THE WRONG BENCHMARK

Here is the flaw hiding inside the relief. Fifteen per cent up is a comparison, and the thing it compares you to is your own past self.

Your past self is a convenient benchmark and a nearly worthless one. Last year’s business was not some objective standard of what is possible. It was just what you happened to do, under last year’s constraints, with last year’s decisions. Beating it tells you that you did better than a fairly arbitrary previous version of yourself. It tells you almost nothing about whether you did well.

The real question was never “did we beat last year.” It is “did we capture what was actually available to us this year.” Those are completely different questions, and growth answers the first one loudly enough that nobody gets around to the second.

GROWTH HIDES UNDERPERFORMANCE BETTER THAN DECLINE EVER COULD

This is the part that should genuinely worry an operator. A bad result and a mediocre-but-positive result are treated completely differently, and the mediocre one is far more dangerous.

A decline forces a reckoning. Numbers go down and the questions come out. Why, what happened, what do we change. Decline is self-correcting, in a sense, because it refuses to be ignored.

Growth has no such mechanism. A fifteen per cent rise that should have been thirty looks, from the outside and from most of the inside, identical to a fifteen per cent rise that was a genuine triumph. The headline is positive either way. So underperformance dressed as growth is the most durable underperformance there is. It can run for years, quietly leaving half the available business on the table every single year, and the annual number going up will protect it the entire time.

You will not be failing. You will just be permanently smaller than you should be, and congratulating yourself annually for it.

ASK WHAT THE CEILING ACTUALLY WAS

The fix is to add one deliberate, uncomfortable question to every good result. Not “did we grow,” but “what was the most this could have been, and why was there a gap.”

Estimate the ceiling honestly. Given the market, the demand, the capacity, the moment, what was genuinely available this year. Then look at the gap between that ceiling and the fifteen per cent you actually got, and treat that gap as the real performance story.

And go and find what lives in the gap. The price rise you did not take. The market you did not enter. The constraint you knew about and did not fix. The hesitation, the late decision, the cautious bet. Those things do not show up in a fifteen per cent rise. They show up only when you go looking for the difference between what happened and what could have, and the good number is precisely what stops you looking.

THE REFRAME

None of this is an argument against being pleased with growth. Growth is good news and a flat or falling business has worse problems. It means growth is good news and not a verdict, and operators keep treating the good news as if the file were now closed.

Your value as an operator is not that you can deliver a number that is higher than last year’s. Time and a half-decent market will often do that on their own. Your value is that you can look at a genuinely good result and still ask, without flinching and without killing the mood, whether it should have been better, and what specifically stopped it.

That is a discipline, and it is a different one from running for growth. It takes the nerve to interrogate a win as hard as you would interrogate a loss, and to benchmark the business against its real potential rather than its own comfortable past. The best operators build that habit deliberately, or they bring in someone who will ask the question a good quarter quietly retires.

Do that, and your good years stop hiding your missed ones. Skip it, and you will keep growing, modestly and reliably, into a fraction of the business you were actually capable of building.

You grew fifteen per cent. Before you celebrate, find out whether it was always supposed to be thirty.

I created this Substack for business owners working too hard for too little return.

Each article draws on 30+ years as a business owner and angel investor to help you diagnose what’s really holding your business back, cut through the noise, make sharper commercial decisions, reduce avoidable risk, and act on the opportunities that actually matter.

Apply what you read, and you’ll stop confusing effort with progress. You’ll see your business more clearly, make better calls, and start fixing the problems costing you money, momentum and confidence.

Want the next article in your inbox?

Subscribe now