“The modern world is not evil; in some ways the modern world is far too good. It is full of wild and wasted virtues. When a religious scheme is shattered (as Christianity was shattered at the Reformation), it is not merely the vices that are let loose. The vices are, indeed, let loose, and they wander and do damage. But the virtues are let loose also; and the virtues wander more wildly, and the virtues do more terrible damage. The modern world is full of the old Christian virtues gone mad. The virtues have gone mad because they have been isolated from each other and are wandering alone. Thus some scientists care for truth; and their truth is pitiless. Thus some humanitarians only care for pity; and their pity (I am sorry to say) is often untruthful.”
— G.K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy
My son always asks questions. Some are innocent and curious. Others dive far deeper than we assume a kid’s thoughts tread. This last week he stopped me flat: “Is truth really black and white?”
My wife and I immediately affirmed that things like truth and justice are black and white. What allows us to see shades of gray isn’t uncertainty; it’s mercy and grace. Facts do not change, but what differs is how we respond to them.
Christianity insists on tempering truth with grace, and who among us could stand a chance if God did not temper His justice with mercy? Separate these virtues, and they don’t remain virtues for long. They become idols.
And if there’s one thing mankind has a history of being good at, it’s creating idols.
I think, given enough time, a theological historian could look back across the generations and identify each one’s favorite virtue by the fruit it produced. In fact, we don’t have to look much further than the last century to begin spotting a pattern.
The Greatest Generation is a paragon of duty. I cannot emphasize enough how noble I find that. In a time of global conflict, teenagers lied about their age just to answer the call to fight for their country and her allies. Meanwhile, back on the home front, selfishness was shameful. No sacrifice was too great if it meant supporting our boys overseas.
What I would give for an ounce of that perseverance in my own life.
That duty built us institutions, and those institutions were built on trust. Trust became assumption—even to this day. Postwar America believed it could solve any problem. As good as that beginning was, our institutions now often feel too bloated and convoluted to fix themselves.
Duty isn’t evil, but duty detached from humility and righteousness eventually forgets whom it was supposed to serve: the people, not itself.
Then we have the Boomers. Despite the Millennial urge to blame them for everything, I still admire their work ethic. What other generation has enjoyed that level of prosperity? Yes, the timing helped, but I won’t deny most of them put in the hours.
It’s why I always thought if I just wrote enough, just worked enough, success would come. If only it were so easy. Even the forty-hour workweek has suffered from inflation.
The Boomers’ success became their identity. Achievement became their morality, and possessions became proof of their virtue. Most Boomers genuinely wanted to raise independent children, and that’s admirable. But too few seem interested in equipping those same children and grandchildren to actually achieve that independence.
Perhaps that’s why I found one statistic so striking: less than a quarter of Boomers intend to leave an inheritance behind. Some even hope to “die with zero” in their bank account—meaning they can enjoy the fruits of their achievements until they’re gone. It’s easy to call them selfish. There is truth to the accusation, but I see something more tragic. Their industry divorced itself from generosity and provision—and that fruit rolled downhill.
Gen X inherited independence and ran with it. Fend for yourself. Distrust the institutions your grandparents built. No one is coming to save you, so you save yourself.
Truthfully, you could write that last sentence about me almost any day.
But here’s the thing: independence without community becomes disengagement. When no one can be trusted, eventually nothing feels worth investing in. Apathy is simply independence left alone too long.
Then there is my generation: the Millennials. Like Paul telling the Corinthians he was born out of due time, I’ve often joked I would’ve made a better Gen Xer or Gen Zer. Why? Because Millennials lead with compassion, and if I’m being honest, compassion has never come naturally to me.
It took me years to appreciate that my generation genuinely wants fewer people to hurt. There’s something deeply Christian about that, which is beautiful, but it misses the mark. Compassion cannot be a standard. Only a lens.
Truth will always be truth. When we make compassion its standard, immutable facts become cruelty, healthy boundaries become exclusion, and justice quietly leaves the conversation.
Remember those institutions we inherited? My generation doesn’t merely ask them to help. We increasingly expect them to eliminate suffering itself. But mercy and grace cannot survive for long once they’ve been separated from truth and justice.
Can you see the conundrum Chesterton so rightly pointed out?
“Thus some scientists care for truth; and their truth is pitiless. Thus some humanitarians only care for pity; and their pity (I am sorry to say) is often untruthful.”
Now we have Gen Z. They’ve given us things like brainrot and TikTok, but honestly, they’re my favorite generation. Beyond their deliciously dark humor, they’re remarkably willing to confront hypocrisy, call out inconsistency, and refuse to ignore suffering. Those are virtues worth celebrating.
But I can foresee justice becoming their idol.
Justice is good and righteous, but it doesn’t heal alone. That’s why God gives us mercy, because justice would require a second flood. Justice alone punishes. I see a desire in this generation to correct—a desire I want to encourage. They’re done with compassion alone, and their apathy is not soft and detached, but vocal.
They do give me hope—but it’s on a knife’s edge. Because justice should never reign alone. If it does, it is the hardest of tyrants.
Every generation thinks it’s here to correct society’s problems. Duty. Success. Independence. Compassion. Justice. All good. All virtues we should aspire to—but we can’t let them play musical chairs for the King’s throne.
My faith never asks me to choose between truth and grace, justice and mercy, or even freedom and submission. It refuses to let a single virtue wander alone, because once a virtue is alone, it demands devotion. None of them were ever meant to rule.
Only Christ is.
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.