There often comes a point in a woman’s life when she realizes she can’t keep carrying the weight of everyone else’s expectations.
Maybe she’s spent years trying to be agreeable, anticipating what others need before they ask, softening the edges of every opinion until no one could possibly find offense and replaying conversations afterward to make sure she didn’t say too much, sound too confident, or leave someone disappointed. She’s learned how to keep the peace, or at least how to keep the appearance of it, and she’s been praised for being easy to work with, easy to talk to, easy to depend upon.
But being easy for everyone else can make a woman… tired.
So when that woman finally begins to understand that other people’s approval is not hers to secure, setting down that burden can feel exhilarating. She discovers that “no” is a complete answer, that another person’s disappointment is not evidence of her failure, and that she can survive being misunderstood. After years of bending herself into whatever shape seemed most acceptable, standing upright feels almost revolutionary.
Some of that freedom is good, necessary, and long overdue.
People-pleasing is not a spiritual gift. Keeping everyone happy is not the same thing as keeping peace, and being endlessly agreeable is not the same thing as being gracious. If the expectations of other people are governing our choices more than the commands of God, then what looks like kindness may actually be fear dressed in respectable clothing.
Paul puts the question plainly in Galatians 1:10:
“For am I now seeking the approval of man, or of God? Or am I trying to please man? If I were still trying to please man, I would not be a servant of Christ.”
Those words leave little room for a life built around managing everyone’s opinion of us. We cannot make human approval our master and still claim to be governed by Christ.
But there is a pitfall waiting on the other side of people-pleasing, and I think many women fall into it precisely because the first taste of release feels so good. We can swing from being controlled by what everyone thinks to refusing to care what anyone thinks. We can mistake defensiveness for confidence, bluntness for courage, and an unwillingness to receive correction for finally “knowing our worth.”
The world celebrates this transformation. It calls an older woman brave when she says exactly what she thinks without regard for how it lands. It praises her for being “brutally honest,” cutting people off without explanation, refusing to apologize, and dismissing anyone who questions her choices as toxic, jealous, or threatened by her growth.
There is an appealing simplicity to this posture. If every uncomfortable voice can be labeled unhealthy, then we never have to ask whether it might be telling us the truth. If every difficult relationship can be discarded in the name of protecting our peace, then we never have to practice patience, confession, forgiveness, or forbearance. If maturity means caring only about our own judgment, we never have to experience the humility of discovering that we were wrong.
But brutality is not a fruit of the Spirit, and becoming unreachable is not the same thing as becoming free.
The Bible doesn’t call us to exchange people-pleasing for pride. It doesn’t free us from the fear of man so that we can become careless with people made in the image of God. It frees us to obey Christ, and obedience to Christ will always shape not only what we say, but also how we say it.
James gives us a picture of wisdom that bears little resemblance to the hard-edged freedom our culture admires.
“But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial and sincere.”—James 3:17
Open to reason.
As I delved into my own season of feeling free to say what I wanted, I found that that phrase was worth sitting with, especially in a culture that treats certainty as strength and correction as an attack. A wise woman is not controlled by every opinion offered to her, but neither is she threatened by the possibility that someone else may see something she does not. She can listen without immediately surrendering her convictions, consider without capitulating, and receive correction without believing her value has been diminished.
This is one of the beautiful differences between people-pleasing and teachability. People-pleasing listens because it is afraid of rejection. Teachability listens because it wants to become wise. People-pleasing changes direction according to whoever is most disappointed. Teachability weighs what it hears against Scripture, seeks the counsel of mature believers, prays for discernment, and remains willing to repent.
The people-pleaser treats every voice as an authority under which to bend, whether she respects it or not. The hardened woman treats no voice as an authority. The wise woman learns which voices have earned weight, while remembering that every human voice remains beneath the authority of God.
This means there will be opinions we must slough off. Some people will misunderstand us because they do not understand the God we are obeying. Some will resent boundaries that prevent them from continuing to benefit from our fear. Some will criticize decisions they were never called to make, and no amount of explaining will satisfy them because understanding was never really what they wanted.
We do not have to spend our lives on trial before people who have already decided the verdict.
At the same time, there will be voices we shouldn’t dismiss merely because their words make us uncomfortable. A faithful friend who has walked with God for decades, a husband who knows the difference between our public composure and our private habits, a pastor who handles Scripture carefully, or a sister in Christ who loves us enough to risk an awkward conversation may be offering exactly the wisdom we have asked God to provide.
Age does not make us exempt from correction. Experience does not make us incapable of self-deception. Having survived painful relationships does not mean every future challenge to us is an attempt at control.
Christian maturity should make us more discerning, but it should also make us more humble.
The goal of getting older is not to become a woman who cares about nothing. It is to become a woman whose concerns are rightly ordered.
She cares what God thinks more than she cares about appearing agreeable. She cares about truth too much to dilute it for approval, but she also cares about love too much to wield it as a weapon. She doesn’t allow the possibility of misunderstanding to govern her mouth, yet she remains willing to examine whether her words and actions reflect the character of Christ.
She can say no without cruelty and yes without resentment. She can let people be disappointed without making their posture her master. She can hold a conviction firmly while speaking with grace, and she can admit that she was wrong without collapsing into shame. She isn’t desperate to be approved of, rather she is deeply committed to being faithful.
That kind of freedom is slower to learn than the freedom promoted in modern culture because it can’t be reduced to a bold declaration or a snarky catchphrase or a list of people or opinions we no longer tolerate. It requires discernment, prayer, and remaining soft enough to be shaped by God after we have become strong enough to stop being shaped by everyone else.
Perhaps that is the question we should ask as we grow older: not merely, “Have I stopped caring what people think?” but, “Have I learned to care most about what God thinks?”
Because the goal isn’t indifference. It’s becoming humble enough to listen, wise enough to discern, gracious enough to speak carefully, and free enough to obey God when others do not understand.
So grow less concerned with being approved of by everyone, friend, and more concerned with being found faithful by Jesus, whose opinion matters most.
In Christ,
Heather
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.