Honors classes are the gold leaf donut of college admissions.
They look fancy. They sound impressive. They make the transcript sparkle a little. Parents see the word Honors and think, “Great, my kid is taking a serious class.”
Sometimes, they’re right on the money. Honors classes can be harder than regular classes. They can prepare students for more advanced work. They can show that a student is willing to challenge themselves.
But…a gold leaf donut is still a donut.
Book A Complimentary Strategy Session
You can pay triple for it. You can take a picture of it. You can admire how expensive it looks. But you cannot actually taste the gold leaf! It does not make the donut more nutritious nor turn dessert into dinner.
Honors classes often require much more work, but they do not always work for students.
A student stays up late working on an Honors Chemistry lab. They grind through Honors English. They take harder tests, do more homework, and feel like they are building the most competitive transcript possible.
But colleges are not just asking, “Did this student take a hard class?”
They are asking, “Did this student take the most rigorous classes available to them?”
An AP class means something nationally. IB means something internationally. Dual Enrollment means a student took an actual college course.
Honors means whatever your high school says it means.
At one school, Honors Biology might be brutal. At another, it might just be regular Biology with extra worksheets and a slightly more dramatic name. Colleges know this.
This is where families get trapped.
A high school might give extra GPA weight for Honors classes, so a student sees a beautiful weighted GPA and feels safe. A 4.6. A 4.8. A 5.1. Everyone relaxes.
But colleges do not have to use your high school’s GPA system.
Many colleges recalculate grades using their own rules. Some strip out non-academic electives. Some focus only on core classes. Some look at unweighted grades and evaluate rigor separately.
So that Honors B that looked “basically like an A” in your school’s system?
A college may still see it as a B.
If the class was Honors rather than AP, IB, or Dual Enrollment, the student may have taken a grade hit without receiving the strongest signal of rigor in return.
Girl, don’t do that.
If your student has access to AP, IB, or Dual Enrollment, those classes usually matter more than Honors.
Not always. Not in every single case. A student should not take AP Physics just to implode emotionally and get a C.
But for a strong student trying to be competitive at selective colleges, the goal is usually to move beyond Honors and into the highest level available. The reason is that you’re proving to the college that you can handle their own coursework.
If you’re in college-level math, that means that you are able to handle the curriculum that they’ll be throwing at you. It’s one of the strongest indicators they can use to gauge how prepared you are to attend their schools.
Some students are not avoiding AP or IB. Their school simply does not offer many advanced courses.
In that case, Honors is not the problem. The lack of access is the problem.
Colleges evaluate students in the context of what their school provides, so a student will not be punished for failing to take AP classes that did not exist.
But if the school’s ceiling is low, we need to find other ways to prove academic strength.
That may mean taking Dual Enrollment, enrolling in a community college course, or an online college-level course that fits the student’s interests.
If your school only serves gold leaf donuts, fine. We will work with that.
But if you need actual academic protein, we may have to go to a different kitchen! (This is my job to do!)
Honors classes are not useless. They can be the right choice when:
A student is not ready for AP yet.
The school requires Honors before AP.
The student can earn an A and build momentum.
The AP version would be too much for that year.
The class is the highest level available at the school.
But before loading up on Honors classes, ask the real question:
Is this actually making the transcript stronger, or does it just look fancy?
You can make the donut sparkle. But AP, IB, and Dual Enrollment are the meal.
No posts
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.