College sports are going through massive changes—from superconference realignment and nonstop transfers to endorsement deal chaos and the class action lawsuit playing out now.
Matt Brown, the publisher behind Extra Points and one of the top experts on the business of college athletics, joined the show to break it all down. We walked through the full history of college sports, the current dynamics, and where things could be headed.
Click here to view the episode transcript | Watch on Youtube | Listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts
➡️ How “bag man” money moves:
Under-the-table booster money, once secretive, is now funneled through "collectives"—501(c)(3) organizations that act like Super PACs for college teams. While technically set up for marketing or charitable appearances, the real intent is often to fund talent acquisition. These funds operate hand-in-glove with athletic departments despite legal separation, and the lack of oversight means both players and donors are vulnerable to empty promises, missed payments, and overall financial murkiness.
➡️ Why the transfer portal is chaos right now:
Until recently, college athletes had to sit out a year after transferring—a rule scrapped after pressure for unfairness. Now, with the rise of the transfer portal and NIL (endorsement) money, college sports has become a form of perpetual free agency. Because athletes aren’t considered employees, anyone can act as an agent without certification, leading to a cottage industry of unregulated intermediaries. These agents often charge steep cuts—sometimes 20% of NIL deals, compared to the 3% standard in pro sports—and are thus financially incentivized to push athletes to transfer frequently, creating a chaotic, money-driven system with little oversight.
➡️ Why most NIL deals have bad ROI for brands:
Matt shared that most NIL brand deals don’t have strong marketing ROI. The value often came from earned media of announcing the campaign, not from the athletes' actual influence. Young athletes, particularly those without marketing skills or experience, often fall short as reputable campaign partners. Brands are realizing that influencer marketing is often better spent on seasoned creators rather than 20-year-olds with limited understanding of campaign performance or deliverables.
More on the possibility of athletes becoming employees and the current class action lawsuit happening in college athletics in the full episode,
If this was helpful to you, please consider forwarding!
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.