RSS Amplifier

Evil Speakers · Aug 25, 2026

Ask A Music Critic: Is Big Thief Playing 29 New Songs Really Preferable To Hearing The Hits?

0
Sign in to vote or save

Steven Hyden · Evil Speakers

Adrianne Lenker of Big Thief (Photo: Genesis Báez)

Thank you for reading Evil Speakers. Please check out Chris Dalla Riva’s recent interview with me, which turned into a two-parter after I spontaneously started talking about the music-writing biz.

Every now and then I like to respond to reader questions. Please feel free to reach out with any pithy or thought-provoking questions via the DM’s! After this week’s primary question related to Big Thief’s recent “all new 29-song triple-album” live set in Nashville, I go through a lightning round of questions about Phoebe Bridgers and songwriting auteurism, Brandon Flowers’ “country accent,” Bob Dylan’s “most Wilburys” album, and a unique battle scenario involving The Strokes and Anthony Fantano.

To all my paying subscribers — thank you for making this newsletter viable!

This week’s first question comes from Evil Speakers subscriber Mitch, who chimes in with a spicy inquiry: I posted a comment in response to Big Thief coming out at the Ryman the other night and playing only new songs from their upcoming album saying I would not enjoy that (picture attached). Then, Gillian Welch (very nicely) called me out.

My question is this: would you enjoy this concert experience? I still stand by my comment that I would be pissed. Spending $100ish dollars to see a band I love and them not playing anything I know for three hours is honestly hell for me. Heck, it’s the reason I generally skip openers. I don’t want to pay money to hear songs I don’t know in a concert setting.

I think if they announced ahead of time, then that is totally cool because then I would be like ok not for me.

Curious on your take.

Read the original on stevenhyden.substack.com

Comments

Nothing yet. Say the first thing.

    Sign in to join the conversation.