In about eight weeks, the Social Security Administration will announce a number, and roughly seventy five million Americans will find out what next year looks like.
The best current estimate is 3.6 percent.
The Senior Citizens League published that projection on August 12. If it holds, it will be the largest cost of living adjustment in four years. For the average retired worker, the monthly check rises from about $2,084 to about $2,159.
Seventy five dollars.
That number is going to get smaller twice before it reaches your account, and only one of those two has ever been explained to you.
Start with the part almost every headline gets backwards.
A bigger COLA is not good news. It cannot be. The COLA rises because prices rose, and that is the entire mechanism. When they tell you seniors are getting their biggest raise in four years, what they are telling you is that this was the most expensive year in four.
The raise is a receipt.
You already know what made this year expensive, because you have been living inside it since February. The war closed the Strait of Hormuz. A fifth of the world’s traded oil stopped moving. Crude went from around sixty dollars a barrel to above a hundred and fifteen. Gasoline followed. Everything that arrives on a truck followed the gasoline.
The inflation figure that feeds your COLA swung like a loose gate all year. It opened 2026 at 2.2 percent. By May it had climbed to 4.4. By June it fell back to 3.5. In July it settled at 3.4 percent.
As of the first week of August, oil was still running about 24 percent above where it stood a year ago.
Here is how directly that reaches your kitchen. Kiplinger’s staff economist David Payne told readers that his 2027 estimate depends on crude. About 3.5 percent if oil stays elevated. About 3.3 percent if it drops in the next thirty days.
Your Social Security raise is now partly set by a waterway between Iran and Oman.
Nobody asked you about the war. Nobody asked you about the blockade. But the tankers that stopped moving in March are an input in the arithmetic that decides your grocery budget for 2027, and not one of the men who made those decisions will ever feel the output.
Medicare Part B premiums are projected to reach about $209.50 a month in 2027, an increase of roughly 3.5 percent. The final figure comes from CMS in the fall.
That money comes out before your check reaches you. You never see it go, so you never quite feel it leave. And if your income puts you above the IRMAA thresholds, the surcharge takes more still.
I want to be fair here, because you should not trust a writer who shows you only the bad half.
Next year’s Part B increase is genuinely mild by recent standards. The 2026 jump was close to 10 percent. After that, 3.5 percent is a relief, and the people who negotiated it down deserve the credit.
So this is not the scandal. The Part B deduction is a known cost, published every year, argued over in the open.
The scandal is upstream, in how your raise was calculated before anybody subtracted anything.
Your COLA comes from an index called the CPI-W.
The Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers.
Urban wage earner. Clerical worker. That is a person who commutes. A person with a paycheck, a car, and a lunch to buy five days a week. It is a fine description of an American.
It is not a description of you.
The CPI-W does more than track prices. It weights them. It decides how much each category counts, based on what a household in that group actually spends. Gasoline for a daily commute carries real weight. Out of pocket healthcare, the kind that lands on a seventy four year old with three prescriptions and a knee that needs looking at, carries much less.
So in a year when medical costs run hot and commuting costs run cool, the index reports that inflation was modest. Your raise is set accordingly. Your actual year was expensive in precisely the categories the formula was built to underweight.
And now the part worth sitting up for.
A better index exists. The government already builds it.
It is called the CPI-E, the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has been calculating it since the 1980s. It uses the same prices and the same formulas as the CPI-W. The single difference is the weighting, drawn from how households with someone aged 62 or older spend their money. Healthcare counts for more. Housing counts for more.
And historically the CPI-E runs higher than the CPI-W, because healthcare has climbed faster than nearly anything else in American life.
The number that describes your life is sitting in a federal database right now. It is calculated. It is published. It is simply not the one they use.
The Senior Citizens League ran the arithmetic on what that costs a person. Someone who retired in 1999 would have collected roughly five thousand dollars more across twenty five years under the CPI-E. Someone who retired in 2014, more than eight thousand.
Now let me be careful about what I am claiming, because you are sharp enough to catch the difference.
Nobody sat in a room and decided to shortchange you. There is no villain in this section, and I am not going to invent one for you.
The COLA formula was written into law in 1972, in a country that ran on factories and paychecks, for a program that was still young. It has been running ever since on a population that changed completely underneath it.
That is the whole problem. The machine is not cruel. The machine is incapable of noticing that the person it measures stopped being an urban wage earner about forty years ago.
A villain you could vote out. A formula nobody has revisited in fifty four years is a harder thing, and it does not care who you voted for.
Thanks for reading St's Substack! This post is public so feel free to share it.
Small errors, compounded annually, stop being small.
The Senior Citizens League publishes a study each year called Loss of Buying Power. The 2026 edition found that compared to 2016, Social Security benefits are now worth about 86.3 cents on the dollar.
To recover what has been lost, they calculate that payments would need to rise 15.7 percent, or about $295.85 a month for the average beneficiary.
Set the two numbers beside each other.
The hole is $295.85.
The raise is $75.
The largest cost of living adjustment in four years covers roughly a quarter of the ground given up in the last ten.
This is not a small group absorbing a small inconvenience. Nearly three quarters of American seniors rely on Social Security for more than half their income. About 44 percent rely on it for all of it. Roughly one in ten, some 5.6 million people, live on less than a thousand dollars a month.
For those 5.6 million, the gap between the CPI-W and the CPI-E is not an economics debate. It decides whether the pharmacy trip happens this month or next.
You cannot change the formula this autumn.
But a window opens in October, it stays open for fifty four days, and there is real money inside it that most eligible people never claim. Everything below is free to pursue.
Re-shop your Part D drug plan. October 15 to December 7.
Drug plans rewrite their formularies every single year. The plan that covered your prescription cheaply in 2026 can drop it, or move it to a costlier tier, in 2027, and the letter telling you so is written to be skimmed. Staying put by default is the most expensive habit in American retirement. Use the Plan Finder at medicare.gov, or call 1-800-MEDICARE and have someone run your actual medication list against every plan in your county.
Get free counseling from SHIP.
Every state runs a State Health Insurance Assistance Program. One on one help, no charge, and critically these are not brokers, so nobody earns a commission from what they recommend to you. Find your state office at shiphelp.org.
Apply for Extra Help if your income is modest.
The Part D Low Income Subsidy cuts premiums, deductibles, and copays, and it is worth thousands of dollars a year. Apply through ssa.gov. Huge numbers of eligible people never apply because they assumed they earned too much. Let the form decide that instead of your guess.
Ask your state about Medicare Savings Programs.
QMB, SLMB, and QI are state run programs that can pay your Part B premium outright. That is the entire $209.50 staying in your check every month instead of leaving it. It is one of the most underclaimed benefits in the country. Call your state Medicaid office and ask for them by name.
Appeal your IRMAA surcharge with Form SSA-44.
Social Security sets your surcharge using your income from two years ago. If your income has since fallen because of retirement, the death of a spouse, or work stoppage, they will keep charging the old rate until you tell them otherwise. The form takes about twenty minutes, and nobody is going to prompt you to file it.
Apply for LIHEAP the first week of October.
Heating assistance opens October 1 in most states, and the money runs out well before the eligible households do. The National Energy Assistance Referral hotline is 1-866-674-6327. If you are already holding a shutoff notice, ask specifically about the crisis grant, which comes from a separate pot.
Run BenefitsCheckUp.org.
Fifteen minutes, free, from the National Council on Aging. It screens you against every assistance program you might qualify for, and it routinely turns up things people had no idea existed.
And one call worth making.
The Social Security 2100 Act was reintroduced this summer. Among other provisions it would switch the COLA calculation from the CPI-W to the CPI-E, and lift the minimum benefit to 125 percent of the federal poverty line. It is unlikely to pass this Congress. Ask anyway, because the bills that get asked about for years are the ones that eventually move. The Capitol switchboard is 202-224-3121. Ask one question and write down the answer: does this office support switching the COLA to the CPI-E, yes or no.
You have spent decades being told the annual raise is your protection.
It was never protection. It is a partial refund on a loss you already absorbed, calculated against a shopping cart that belongs to a commuter who does not live in your house.
That is worth being angry about. It is also worth being precise about, because precision is the difference between anger that wears you out and anger that goes somewhere.
Here is what you have now that most people in your position do not. You know the index has a name. You know a better one already sits finished in a government office. You know the exact fifty four day window where unclaimed money is waiting, and you know the seven doors inside it.
Most of your neighbors will read the October headline, feel briefly relieved about seventy five dollars, and claim none of it.
You do not have to be one of them. Not this year.
One note on the numbers. The 3.6 percent figure is a projection, updated monthly as new inflation data arrives. September’s CPI release lands before the official announcement, so the final number will move. The gap between the CPI-W and the CPI-E will not.
The Senior Citizens League, “COLA Projection Falls to 3.6% With 2 Months Remaining to 2027 Announcement,” August 12, 2026. https://seniorsleague.org/cola-projection-falls-to-3-6-with-2-months-remaining-to-2027-announcement/
The Senior Citizens League, COLA Watch. https://seniorsleague.org/cola-watch/
Yahoo Finance, “Seniors could see a bigger raise in 2027, according to new Social Security COLA estimate,” August 2026. https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/article/seniors-could-see-a-bigger-raise-in-2027-according-to-new-social-security-cola-estimate-142217210.html
Kiplinger, “Social Security COLA 2027.” https://www.kiplinger.com/retirement/social-security/social-security-cola-2027
The Motley Fool, “Here’s How the 2027 Social Security COLA Is Projected to Stack Up to the 2026 COLA,” August 16, 2026. https://www.fool.com/retirement/2026/08/16/heres-how-the-2027-social-security-cola-is-project/
News4JAX, “Social Security 2027 COLA projected at 3.8% by Senior Citizens League,” August 3, 2026. https://www.news4jax.com/news/local/2026/08/03/social-security-2027-cola-projected-at-38-by-senior-citizens-league/
Congressional Research Service, “A Hypothetical Social Security Cost-of-Living Adjustment Based on the Research Consumer Price Index for the Elderly.” https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/IF12675
National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, “The CPI-E: A Better Option for Calculating Social Security COLAs.” https://www.ncpssm.org/documents/social-security-policy-papers/the-cpi-e-a-better-option-for-calculating-social-security-colas/
Fox Business, “Should the Social Security COLA be measured with a senior-focused inflation metric?” https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/should-social-security-cola-measured-senior-focused-inflation-metric
Social Security Administration, Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) Information. https://www.ssa.gov/news/en/cola/index.html
Medicare Plan Finder and Open Enrollment. https://www.medicare.gov
SHIP National Network. https://www.shiphelp.org
National Council on Aging, BenefitsCheckUp. https://www.benefitscheckup.org
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.