Reading · The Bigger Picture

I wish good essays could pay rent on their own.
Until they learn how, paid subscriptions keep this publication alive.

Become a (Paid) Subscriber

Here’s something I think we’ve completely misunderstood. A meaningful life isn’t built by collecting possibilities. It’s built by murdering them. Horrible word, I know. But I can’t think of a more honest one. Every serious commitment destroys hundreds of other futures. That’s what makes it serious. If nothing dies, nothing has really been chosen.

We spend years pretending we can outsmart this. We’ll have the exciting career and endless freedom. The family and total independence. The peaceful life and constant adventure. We keep trying to squeeze five lives into one body. Then we wonder why nothing ever receives the whole of us.

Whether you decide or not, the alternatives keep disappearing. Careers close. Parents grow old. Bodies change. Children are born to other people. Cities become memories before you’ve ever lived there. We imagine we’re preserving our options, while time walks behind us locking every door we were too afraid to close ourselves.

Most people don’t ruin their lives by making terrible decisions. They ruin them by living permanently in the doorway. Never fully entering. Never fully leaving. Mistaking hesitation for wisdom until decades disappear behind them.

You don’t become exhausted because you chose one life, but because you never let the lives you didn’t choose die.

Reality has to earn what fantasy receives for free. Every life you actually choose becomes ordinary. It collects routines, disappointments, bills, misunderstandings and days where nothing ever happens. Then you spend years comparing your real life against imaginary ones and wondering why reality keeps losing.

Your imagination has been lying to you for years. You didn’t discover that those other lives were better. You protected them from ever proving they weren’t. You kept them frozen at their most beautiful moment and forced your actual life to age, struggle and bleed in front of you. Then you called the comparison evidence.

You’re judging one life by everything it became and all the others by everything they promised. One had to keep showing up. The rest disappeared before they could disappoint you. That’s not wisdom. That’s cheating.

The grass on the other side stays green because nobody has ever had to live there.

We are the only species capable of inventing imaginary worlds, comparing them against reality and then blaming reality for falling short. A dog does not wonder if another owner would have loved him more. A bird does not spend its life mourning every sky it never crossed. Somehow we became the only creatures capable of being homesick for places we’ve never been.

Sometimes we don’t fear failure.
Sometimes we fear evidence.

Because failure would force us to meet reality.
But possibility lets us remain endlessly exceptional in our own imagination.

They have never been rejected, embarrassed, ignored, criticized, or forced to discover their limits.

We spend years comparing ourselves to someone who has never experienced the one thing every real person must endure: finding out who they actually are.

We have somehow managed to create a fantasy version of ourselves that receives more patience, more forgiveness, and more belief than the actual person fighting through the day.

We excuse the imaginary self because they are full of potential.

We criticize the real self because they are full of flaws.

The absurd part is that the imaginary one has never done anything to deserve our loyalty, while the real one has survived every single thing life has thrown at them.

The futures you never lived were never asked to pay the price of existing. They never had to keep a marriage together, bury a parent, recover from heartbreak, pay rent or wake up to another ordinary morning after the excitement had faded. They remained beautiful because they remained untouched. They never had to prove a single thing. Your real life did. And somehow we’ve spent years judging reality for having the courage imagination never needed.

We’ve been holding our real life responsible for every life it prevented. Every difficult season becomes evidence that another future would have been easier. Every ordinary day becomes proof that another road would have been more exciting. We ask one fragile human life to justify the disappearance of every possibility we ever loved. No reality could survive a trial that brutal.

Sometimes I wonder how many people aren’t actually unhappy with their lives. They’re just exhausted from defending them. Every difficult week becomes another debate. Every disappointment another cross-examination. Every mistake another opportunity for the imaginary life to stand up and say, “See? You should’ve chosen me.”

Imagine giving everything you have to someone for decades, only to realize they’ve spent the whole time wondering whether somebody else would’ve loved them better. That’s exactly what we’ve been doing to the only life we’ve ever had.

The illusion isn’t believing another life would’ve been perfect, but believing your real life has to defeat every imaginary one before it deserves your love. We have made our loyalty conditional on winning a competition that was impossible from the very beginning. No wonder so many people spend decades feeling as though they’ve fallen short.

There is something profoundly lonely about being loved half-heartedly. About always sensing that someone’s imagination lives somewhere else. I wonder whether our lives have been carrying that loneliness for years, waiting for us to come home to the only place we have ever truly existed.

The life you never lived will never miss you. It never laughed with you, buried your loved ones, held your trembling hands or carried your mistakes. But this life did. Perhaps it’s time to stop loving the one that never existed more than the one that never left.

Support These Essays

Share The Bigger Picture

I don’t love asking for support.
I do love writing these pieces.

If you’d like to help me write more essays,
a paid subcription is the best way to do it.

Either way, I’m glad you’re here.

Become a Paid Subscriber

If this has earned a coffee,
I promise it’ll become another essay.