I Asked This One Question to Estate Agents — None Could Answer It.

I went undercover as a property investor, asking estate agents a question that cut through the usual sales talk: "I want to buy two residential properties in London and my main goal is to preserve purchasing power over the long-term, which two boroughs should I pick?”

Alternatively, I could have posed a slightly more challenging question: “Which two boroughs have, on average, an 80% or higher probability of preserving property purchasing power over the long term?”

That’s a very different ask. It moves beyond hype and headlines into the realm of evidence-based decision-making — and it’s where some estate agents fall short.

It was an eye-opening exercise.

Some quickly suggested the usual suspects — Kensington, Chelsea, Notting Hill — prestige postcodes that scream “safe haven” but come with ultra-high entry costs. Others pushed me toward regeneration areas like Barking or Croydon, often with promises of “upside potential”.

But here’s the issue: very few could back up their suggestions with data, long-term price trends, inflation changes, or even a basic explanation of how certain areas tend to preserve value better than others.

So I started doing my own research.

Let’s start with a bit of math.

London has 33 boroughs (technically 32 + City of London). If you’re picking 2 for a property investment, that’s 528 possible combinations. Add a third, and you’re staring at 5,456 options(!!!).

To put that into perspective, here’s what 528 combinations look like: a dizzying web of choices, with each line below connecting a unique pair of boroughs. I asked estate agents to name just two that could preserve my purchasing power long-term. Not one could answer.

In investment terms, this means looking for assets — in this case, properties — that grow at least in line with inflation over time. Ideally, you want real growth: value appreciation above inflation.

So what drives that in the London property market?

• Scarcity — limited housing stock in desirable areas

• Infrastructure — proximity to transport, schools, parks

• Economic resilience — employment hubs, affluence, universities

• Lifestyle appeal — safety, walkability, community identity

• Sustained demand through economic cycles

In my research, I calculated the probability that property prices in each London borough outpace inflation over 3-, 5-, and 10-year rolling timeframes.

The goal? To identify which boroughs have historically offered the most consistent protection against the erosion of purchasing power — not just during market booms, but across multiple economic cycles.

No Single Winner: Crucially, no borough seems to guarantee top performance across all timeframes. The "best" place based on this data really depends on the investment horizon.

Short-term bets (3-5 Years) - Good, not great: Over 3 and 5 years, the chances of preserving purchasing power are decent but far from certain. Top performing boroughs like Camden, Westminster, Hackney, Kensington & Chelsea, and Richmond upon Thames lead the pack.

Long-term horizon (10 Years) - Incredible resilience: This is where the story gets dramatic. The likelihood of preserving purchasing power jumps significantly across the board over a decade.

• Perfect Scores: A surprising number of boroughs, often further out, show a 100% probability based on this historical data! These include Bromley, Enfield, Greenwich, Harrow, Hillingdon, Lewisham, Newham, Redbridge, Sutton, and Waltham Forest.

• Near Perfect: Many others are extremely close to 100%, like Bexley, Barnet, Hounslow, Kingston, Merton, and Ealing.

• Slightly disappointing: The top short-term performers like Camden, Westminster, and Kensington & Chelsea have relatively lower (though still high!) probabilities over 10 years compared to the 100% group.

Perhaps the most striking finding is that every single London borough listed shows at least a 90% probability of preserving purchasing power over a 10-year period based on this data. This suggests that, historically, holding London property for a decade has been a very strong bet against inflation, regardless of the specific borough.

Few agents brought up long-term economic trends or historical price data. None mentioned inflation or the idea of real returns (price growth minus inflation). And yet, this is crucial. A 4% annual price rise when inflation is running at 6% means you're actually losing ground. This gap in perspective underscores why understanding real returns is non-negotiable for any property investor.

Over shorter horizons like 3-5 years, London property has historically offered decent odds of preserving purchasing power, but it’s hardly a sure bet—especially when inflation spikes, as it has in recent periods. Boroughs like Camden, Westminster, and Kensington & Chelsea shine here, though even they can stumble.

Stretch that timeline to 10 years, however, and the picture transforms. Nearly every borough boasts a 90%+ probability of outpacing inflation, with surprising outer areas hitting perfect 100% scores based on this data.

Time is the ultimate ally in London’s property game. While no borough is immune to short-term wobbles, a decade-long hold has historically turned the market into a near-unbeatable hedge against the slow bleed of inflation.

Protecting purchasing power isn’t about chasing the hottest borough or timing the next boom—it’s about playing the long game. London’s resilience over 10 years suggests that patience, more than postcode prestige, is what delivers real growth. So, whether you’re eyeing a flat in Hackney or a semi in Sutton, numbers suggests the same advice: back your decisions with data, hold on, and let time do the heavy lifting.

Hit the like button if you liked it or forward this email with someone who’s also navigating the London property market.

Disclaimer:

The information provided in this article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. While the analysis is based on historical data from ONS - January 1995 to December 2024, past performance is not indicative of future results. Property values can fluctuate, and individual outcomes may vary depending on timing, location, and other factors. Always conduct your own research and consider seeking advice from a qualified professional before making any investment decisions.