An evolution of the movie therapist

Hi, I am also writing for the publication Psychology Today, where I have a column called Reel Therapy. Please check it out and leave a coment comment. Thank you for your support.

In these 10 films listed below, ranging from 1945 to 2026, I examine the evolution of the film therapist archetype. There are so many good films I could add to this list, such as Annie Hall or Freud, but ultimately, I settled on these ten (for now). Fears, anxieties, and fantasies about how we view therapists, in relation to what is going on in our society and culture, project themselves onto the screen. From paternal, rational expert to the unreliable, traumatized therapist, we can see a total inversion of the therapist portrayal.1 Please leave a comment if you know of a great film or television portrayal of a therapist I should check out.

1. Spellbound (1945) - Director: Alfred Hitchcock Streaming: AppleTV Hitchcock’s portrayal of a therapist in this film is often celebrated as the first to visually depict a Freudian psychoanalytic approach to the subconscious, so he enlisted one of the most subversive artists of the day, Surrealist pioneer Salvador Dalí. Dr. Constance Petersen (Ingrid Bergman) is an analyst and heroic expert treating her patient (Gregory Peck), but she crosses an ethical and legal boundary when she romantically falls for him, blurring the boundaries between love and analysis.

2. Three Faces of Eve (1957) - Director: Nunnally Johnson Stream: YouTube

   Dr. Curtis Luther (Lee J. Cobb) is portrayed as a paternal, rational authority figure. He uses fatherly tactics with Eve in a classic 1950s “doctor knows best” style. Psychiatry often reflected traditional societal expectations, such as the “housewife syndrome,” which was commonly treated with tranquilizers, rather than trying to understand the underlying social pressures on women that may be contributing to their unhappiness. In his sessions with Eve, Dr. Luther uses hypnosis to navigate between her 3 personalities and finds a single childhood memory that fixes everything. The film positions his authority as infallible and complete.

   

3. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975) - Director: Miloš Forman Stream: Prime

   In the seventies, individual perceptions of institutions, gender, war, and more began to shift from trust to distrust, and that showed in many of the best films of the time. With the rise of the anti-psychiatry movement (Thomas Szasz’s The Myth of Mental Illness) and post-Watergate distrust of institutions, the therapist is no longer the heroic savior or expert but a coercive means of control. In One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, Nurse Ratched (Louise Fletcher) conducts group therapy as if it were an interrogation, using the clients’ vulnerabilities against them rather than offering insights to help them.

4. Ordinary People (1980) - Director: Robert Redford Stream: PlutoTV

   This eighties movie brought another huge shift in what therapy means. Redford directs a film that shows therapy as human-centered, empathetic, and kind. Dr. Tyrone Berger (Judd Hirsch) is a real person in a modest office setting who develops a trusting connection (Rodgerian) with his client using humor and kindness in a therapeutic relationship. The doctor gives a young Timothy Hutton permission to feel, which ultimately helps the client.

   

5. Good Will Hunting (1997) - Director: Gus Van Sant Stream: PlutoTV

   Dr. Maguire (Robin Williams) embodies one of the most beloved examples of a therapist. He comes across as “anti-clinical” in a messy office, telling crude jokes, and approaching therapy in an “out of the box” way. Instead of being the “expert,” Maguire taps into his own experience of having dealt with trauma to reach clients, aka the Jungian “wounded healer.”

   

6. Donnie Darko(2001) - Director: Richard Kelly Stream: YouTube

   Dr. Lilian Thurman (Katharine Ross) uses hypnotherapy to delve into Donnie’s subconscious. Coming from a more existential therapeutic approach. She takes his thoughts and hallucinations seriously and comforts him by asking about life’s bigger questions. This therapist does not dismiss Donnie as having an “illness” that needs to be fixed, but recognizes that anxiety is part of the human condition.

7. Anger Management (2003) - Director: Peter Segal Stream: Prime

   Dr. Buddy Rydell (Jack Nicholson) is not calm and rational like Dr. Berger (Ordinary People) or a “wounded healer” like Dr. Maguire (Good Will Hunting), but chaotic, loud, provocative, manipulative, boundaryless, and a highly unconventional “celebrity” therapist. He becomes the villain to the client, who becomes his experiment. This definitely plays into a growing skepticism of therapy’s unchecked power and possibly a nod to aversion therapy, which historically has been misused while violating patient autonomy. Dave Buznik (Sandler), who seems sweet and like someone who is never really upset, gets labeled “angry,” and then that label comes to completely define him. As a result, Dave gets tasered, faces jail time, is threatened with losing his job, is dumped by his girlfriend, and is basically tortured in order to “rid him” of his anger.

Share