Why the Most Talented People Fall Apart When It Matters Most

NOTE: I’m surveying people about their experiences performing under pressure (music, sports, life, etc.). I’d love to hear from you - click here to take the 2-minute quiz.

You’ve done this a thousand times. You know it cold.

And then the moment arrives. The room is watching, or the recording light is on, or someone you respect is listening.

And, suddenly, you feel like an inept beginner. As if you’ve stepped into someone else’s body.

Your hands won’t cooperate. Your mind is freaking the hell out. It feels like every eyeball on the planet is judging you, and the verdict is not good. Who is this impostor, they must be thinking.

It’s the kind of experience you never want to have again.

Naturally, you chalk it up to a lack of preparation. You just weren’t as good as you thought you were. You should have practiced harder. Or different.

But the thing is, you did prepare. You put in the work. It wasn’t that the skills weren’t there.

It was that, somehow, when you needed them the most, they vanished.

Two figure skaters at the 2026 Winter Olympics just showed us both sides of this story in the most vivid way possible. And what their contrasting performances reveal is not what most people think.

Ilia Malinin is one of the most gifted figure skaters who has ever lived. The first person to land a quad axel in competition, a jump so difficult that until recently it was considered physically impossible.

He had been undefeated internationally since late 2023. According to the expert commentators, a gold medal was as inevitable as death and taxes.

And then the unthinkable happened.

He fell twice. He made errors on jumps he has landed thousands of times. When the verdict from the judges came, he dropped from first place to eighth, out of medal contention.

Afterward, Malinin was searingly honest about what happened. “I just felt like all the traumatic moments of my life really just started flooding my head,” he said. “So many negative thoughts just flooded in there. And I just did not handle it.”

He had felt ready. He had felt confident. But in his own words: “I didn’t understand how much the pressure was really going to get to me.”

Then, a week later, Alysa Liu took the ice for the women’s free skate.

She was not the favorite. She had retired from skating at 16, burned out and struggling, and only returned two years later on her own terms.

In her final skate, she delivered the performance of her life. A performance that earned a gold medal, the first for an American woman in singles figure skating in over two decades.

Afterward, she described what it felt like: “I was peak happiness when I was out there on the ice. Nothing could bring me higher than that.”

The knee jerk narrative is that one of them choked and the other didn’t.

But that’s an oversimplification that misses what’s actually interesting. It ignores and trivializes the complexity of what they’re trying to pull off, and all that they must overcome in order to do it.

Malinin is not weak. Liu is not simply tough.

Something specific happened in their brains. And what separates them is not talent, not preparation, not mental toughness.

We’re all familiar with the voice in our head. Our internal narrator. The one whose sole obsession is you.

It’s job is to tell the story of who you are. To yourself and to the rest of that world.

Though it can feel like the totality of who you are, the reality it is that voice is only the tiniest fraction. One little brain network amongst thousands.

The self-network, which sits in the prefrontal cortex, has a narrow job. It’s the public relations arm of your conscious mind. Under ordinary circumstances it does that job without causing much trouble.

The problems arise when it detects a threat to the story it’s been telling to you and the rest of the world. Because, in its eyes, a threat to your identity is a threat to your survival. If your identity dies, you die.

So if that identity is "musician" or "great student" or "world's best figure skater," any scenario where that identity is on the line becomes a life-or-death situation. Playing in your first jam session and facing an approaching grizzly bear trigger the same alarm system.

First, it sounds the alarm. Heart rate spikes, hands shake, muscles tense.

And second, it tries to take over the controls. At the exact moment when you need your hard-won automatic skills firing on all cylinders, the self module steps in and says I got this one. This is too important to leave to the amateurs.

But there’s only one problem: your conscious mind doesn’t actually know how to do anything.

It can narrate. It can evaluate. It can worry.

But it cannot play a piece of music, land a quad axel, or give a coherent speech. It is an inept beginner. A backseat driver who’s never operated a motor vehicle, suddenly taking the wheel. Predictably, you crash and burn.

Listen to Malinin: “It’s just a lot on you, just so many eyes, so much attention.” That’s self consciousness, perfectly described.

At the moment when the self needed to exit the scene, it took center stage.

The default response to performing badly under pressure is to practice more. More discipline, more hours, more repetition.

And it sounds right. It feels like the responsible answer.

There’s even a wise-sounding adage that goes “Amateurs practice until they get it right. Professionals practice until they can’t get it wrong.”

But it misses what’s actually causing the breakdown in this scenario.

Practice builds the automatic system. It trains the fast, fluid, skilled part of the brain that produces great performance. That part is essential.

But it has nothing to do with choking.

Malinin’s skills were literally the best in the world. That much is unquestioned. He had built the necessary neural software for a gold medal performance.

But all the practice in the world doesn’t teach the self-module to get out of the way.

During her short program, Liu looked into the stands and found her four younger siblings, her father, and her best friend. She didn’t look away. “I performed to the people,” she later explained. “They’re right there, so I performed to them specifically.”

When a reporter suggested her family might be a distraction, her response was immediate: “My family is not a distraction. They’re the only reason why I’m here.”

What was Liu focusing on during her performance? Or, importantly, what was she not focused on.

Her self.

Liu’s attention was directed outward. Toward the people she was performing for. Toward the music. Toward the story she was telling on the ice. And when attention goes outward like that, the self-module has nothing to grab onto. It goes quiet. The automatic system runs uninterrupted.

After winning gold, Liu held up her medal and said something remarkable: “I don’t need this. But what I needed was a stage, and I got that. So I was all good, no matter what.”

This is the part of Liu’s story people can’t stop talking about. How could an Olympian not care about winning a medal? How could she not care about the result? Isn’t that the whole point of it all?

For most athletes, it is. And that's exactly why choking is so common. When you care about the result, everything becomes about you. Am I good enough? Will they judge me? What happens if I fail? The self network is fully engaged, and silencing it becomes nearly impossible. Athletes and performers spend entire careers devising tricks and rituals to neutralize its influence.

Liu didn’t stop caring. She cared enormously. She cried after her short program. She screamed after her free skate. But she redirected what she cared about. Not the score. Not the judgment. The people. The music. The stage itself. “My goal is just to do my programs and share my story,” she said. “Whether I beat them or not is not my goal.”

What people see as extraordinary about Liu is her mindset. It feels like a paradox. But it may be one of the most important lessons in all of human performance: we do our best work when we stop making it about ourselves, and turn our attention to what truly matters.

(Related: If you haven’t taken the 2-minute survey on your own experiences performing under pressure, click here to do so)