The Craft of Communications: Going from Apprentice to Mastery

Every civilization had its communicators; the scribes, heralds, town criers, diplomats, and editors who shaped the stories nations told about themselves.

The modern communications professional stands in that lineage. Yet, in today’s corporate hierarchies, the role is often seen as cosmetic.

The craft of communications has built empires and ended wars. It is a hard skill disguised as a soft one. It requires fluency in psychology, power dynamics, timing, and tone. Like architecture or cuisine, it’s a discipline of craft learned through apprenticeship, repetition, and reflection, not charisma alone.

It also demands years of deliberate practice, pattern recognition across thousands of scenarios, and the kind of embodied judgment that can’t be taught in a workshop.

Inspired by Richard Sennett’s The Craftsman and Robert Greene’s Mastery, today’s newsletter examines the path of mastery for the comms professional.

Every great communicator, whether in politics, corporate affairs, or global development, walks a version of this path. The titles may differ, but the journey is remarkably consistent: apprentice, journeyman, adept, and master.

Common job titles: Communications Intern, Junior Copywriter, Assistant PR Officer, Social Media Associate, Editorial Assistant. (Caveat: Titles are not consistent across industries. Don’t confuse your title with your stage. Some “assistants” have become adept, some “managers” are still apprentices.)

Every craft begins with imitation.

In this first stage, you’re not expected to innovate but rather, to copy with precision.

Apprenticeship is about learning the grammar of the industry - the difference between a holding statement and a positioning memo, how to structure a media brief, when to escalate and when to hold. You build what cognitive scientists call “chunking”, the ability to recognize patterns instantly because you’ve seen the components hundreds of times.

The apprentice’s goal is fluency, not fame. What folks call, putting in the reps.

Consider Bozoma Saint John. Before her high-profile brand leadership roles at Pepsi, Apple/Beats, Uber, and Netflix, Saint John has described early years doing whatever needed doing at Spike Lee’s SpikeDDB e.g. fetching coffee, fixing machines, marking up scripts, absorbing how great campaigns are made by doing the small things well.

This stage is unglamorous but essential to building muscle memory.

The apprentice learns tools, like media monitoring systems, content management platforms, stakeholder mapping frameworks. But more importantly, they learn to see the “lay of the land”.

To level up:

• Develop consistency: deliver reliable, accurate, timely work.

• Seek mentors who model excellence.

• Volunteer for unseen tasks such as editing, summarizing, synthesizing. These train your eye for structure, which becomes the backbone of judgment later.

Common job titles: Communications Officer, PR Executive, Content Strategist, Digital Marketing Specialist, Media Relations Coordinator, Speechwriter.

If apprenticeship is about obedience, the journeyman phase is about experimentation. You’ve mastered the fundamentals and can finally execute without supervision.

You write the press release without three rounds of edits. You run the stakeholder workshop. You manage the product launch end-to-end.

This is where taste develops through trial and repetition.

The journeyman stage is messy. You lead projects but haven’t yet developed a distinctive approach. Research on skill development calls this the “conscious competence” phase. You can do the work well, but it requires deliberate attention.

Many professionals end up here and plateau. Only a handful advance.

The trick to advancement in this stage is: diversification and reflection.

The best journeymen deliberately seek varied experiences. Draft speeches for executives with wildly different styles. Manage a crisis in one domain, a culture transformation in another. Handle media in three different regulatory environments. Each context adds new patterns to your library.

For all the complaints about the PR agency, it is heaven for journeymen. You get to try your hands on different projects, across different industries, with different clients.

But you do not have to work in an agency to experiment. You just need courage and curiosity. And when you find yourself in a rut in an industry, it’s time to change employers.

To level up:

• Diversify your experiences.

• Keep professional journals (sort of like analytical logs). What worked in that campaign? What assumptions did I make that proved wrong? What would I do differently? This metacognitive practice, documented in studies of expert performance, accelerates the transition from execution to insight.

• Stop seeking applause and start seeking concrete feedback.

Common job titles: Senior Strategist, Head of Communications, Comms Lead, Head of Content, Brand Lead, Corporate Affairs Advisor, or External Relations Specialist.

Something changes when you reach the adept stage. You begin to sense the invisible architecture of communication, like the power of silence, the psychology of framing and sequencing.

You can diagnose communication problems the way an experienced architect spots structural issues in a blueprint intuitively, often before others recognize something’s wrong. You make complex decisions that appear simple. You balance what’s said with what’s deliberately left unsaid or implied.

This is when you start developing your own frameworks distilled from your accumulated experience.

Take Richard Edelman, the head of Edelman, one of the world’s biggest independent PR firms. Over two decades ago, when he reframed public relations as trust management, he wasn’t polishing old language; but rather exposing the underlying dynamics of influence. His annual Trust Barometer turned a communications product into a strategic tool for leadership.

At this stage, you also begin mentoring others. Not because you’re required to, but because teaching clarifies your thinking. Explaining why a message works forces you to articulate principles you’ve been operating on instinctively.

To level up:

• Study allied disciplines: organizational behavior, behavioral science, diplomacy, design thinking.

• Hone situational awareness - learn how power, timing, and perception interact.

• Develop your philosophy of the craft: What do you believe communication is for?

Common job titles: Chief Communications Officer, Director of Strategic Communications, Senior Advisor, Thought Leader, or Founder of a communications firm.

This is every professional’s Eldorado.

The master has moved beyond technique and embodied the discipline.

Your intuition operates where formulas fail. In crisis moments when others are paralyzed by ambiguity, you can move with clarity. Not because you have a playbook for every scenario. But because you’ve internalized principles so deeply that you can improvise elegantly within constraints.

Masters lead through their work, with their satisfaction coming from developing others who will surpass them.

This is where legacy thinking emerges. Not legacy as vanity, but legacy as responsibility i.e. institutionalizing wisdom so the next generation doesn’t start from zero. Master communicators write the frameworks that become industry standards. They create training programs that shape how organizations think about communication. They mentor across disciplines, recognizing that craft excellence in one domain can illuminate another.

How to level up:

Mastery presents a paradox. Contrary to popular belief, mastery is not a final stage. Every master eventually returns to apprenticeship in a new domain, for example, writing a book, launching a venture, mentoring across disciplines. True mastery is recursive. You begin again, better.

Organizations are facing increased complexity. Polarized audiences, algorithms, stakeholder expectations that shift overnight etc. The “soft skills” approach isn’t working. We need professionals who’ve developed the judgment that only comes through years of deliberate practice.

When we treat communication as a craft with clear developmental stages, several things change:

• We stop hiring for credentials alone and start assessing where candidates actually are in their craft development. An apprentice with five years of experience isn’t the same as an adept with five years of experience.

• We build better development programs. You don’t teach an apprentice the same way you challenge a journeyman or develop an adept. Each stage requires different experiences, different feedback, different growth opportunities.

• Lastly, we create clearer career pathways. Professionals can assess their own development and identify what they need to advance, not just what title to chase, but what capabilities to cultivate.

We are heirs to a noble lineage, from scribes who recorded the rise of civilizations to editors who shaped the modern public sphere. To call communications a “soft skill” is to misunderstand what keeps organizations thriving.

For peers, today’s newsletter is diagnostic, helping you identify where you are and how to begin to level up. For leaders, it can help you design environments where your comms team can thrive - pairing apprentices with masters, allowing journeymen to experiment, etc.

We inherit the craft but we also shape its future, 10,000 hours per person.

If you enjoyed reading this newsletter, please like the post and share with your network. Inclusion Notes keeps growing every week and it’s due to people sharing it with their friends and colleagues.