RSS Amplifier

The Podcast Critic Newsletter - Great Pods · Mar 31, 2025

Tonight! The Ambies Award - Watch Live Now!

0
Sign in to vote or save

Captain Ron - Great Pods · The Podcast Critic Newsletter - Great Pods

Hey Poddy People!

We are busy bees over here! My disappearance from Ramadan is over, politics is all-consuming, and I ran the LA Marathon Big 5k in support of K9Youth Alliance. The 5k is the only distance I could handle while fasting. Remember to say Happy Eid, or Eid Mubarak to your Muslim friends!

It’s also been busy since I launched the new podcast submission form, and I’ve been working on a page for the critics/reviewers to access their reviews. It’s a lot more difficult in trying to connect the dots in programming than I thought it was. Enough nerd-talk…

critics
Critic’s Corner in progress

Let’s GOOOOOOOOO!

The Round-Up

On to my picks this week…

Podcast: IMO w/ Michelle Obama and Craig Robinson
Genre: Society, Conversational
Publisher: Higher Ground

About: Michelle Obama and her big brother Craig Robinson bring their unique experiences and candid perspectives to a range of listeners’ personal dilemmas, from the everyday to the existential. Each week, they’re joined by special guests to tackle audience questions with practical advice, relatable anecdotes, and plenty of laughs. From dating and relationships to parenting and financial planning, IMO sees the iconic First Lady at her most relaxed and honest. This podcast will leave you laughing, reflecting, and feeling more prepared to tackle life’s challenges.

I’m leaving more in today and placing the other two recs later this week.

I have been only able to find mostly 2-star critic reviews of the pod, and that’s not a bad thing; however, amidst the constructive low star reviews, it still made me want to listen. Now, will I get past the initial two episodes remains to be seen or heard.

In My Opinion, it was good. It’s more serious than the comedy “We’re Here To Help” and a little more personal, like Sibling Revelry with Kate Hudson and Oliver Hudson, but maybe not as in-depth just yet. If you like Michelle, you’ll like this podcast. If you don’t like Michelle’s politics but like her, you’ll like this podcast. There is no partisan type of political chatter here. It’s about each other. I think maybe some reviewers got lost because they wanted a political, democratic response to what is happening in the US at this moment. This is not that podcast.

I have to be transparent as well; none of the reviews are from Black writers. I think that perspective is needed for additional context around the podcast. I encourage any Black writers that read this: We need more professional reviews.

If there is anything I’ve learned via social media in the last ten years, it is that Black and immigrant communities are eerily similar in our upbringings. Even though Pine-Sol is a sponsor, their first conversation about cleaning and using Pine-Sol was seamless but also relatable to me, too. I can hear my mom now talking about getting the Pine-Sol out for me to clean.

I have to say that there’s comedy if you see it. Craig speaking of sponsor, Colonguard is sorta funny because it’s not a pod ad we’re used to. Colonguard?

Sir, this is a Wendy’s. Anyway, I was expecting a betterhealth.com ad, and guess what? I got one. I do hope Michelle and Craig can find their podcast voice and start to expand their conversational depth.

Issa Rae was the first celebrity guest, and the conversation was fine.

Miranda Sawyer • The Guardian

“Michelle...is an immensely impressive person, but her “go high” positivity is reduced to platitudes here. There was the odd insightful moment”

My Opinion or Yours?

‘Top of the Pods’ this past week on Great Pods:

5. Khloé in Wonder Land - Khloé Kardashian

4. Scam Factory - Wondery

3. The Broken Veil - Cheese, Pickle

2. The Telepathy Tapes - Ky Dickens

1. The Severance Podcast - Audacy

Stay safe, be kind, and feed the needy.

Listening with you,
Captain Ron

Great Pods is your best friend in podcast discovery. Get immersed in engaging critic reviews and ratings to help you decide on your next podcast listen. Tell a friend!

Read the original on greatpods.substack.com

Comments

Nothing yet. Say the first thing.

    Sign in to join the conversation.