▶️ Watch & Listen to this Episode Here!
I sit in rooms with partners who built entire careers on knowing exactly how many hours something takes. Ask them about an investigation, a complex matter that requires judgment at scale, and they can tell you the phases, the timeline, the staffing model, down to the hour. That knowledge, skill, and expertise is their credential. It’s what justifies their rate. It’s what gets them the room in the first place.
But what happens when you take that away?
Technology can now do some of the same work in a fraction of the time, at a level of polish that used to take a team days to produce. The hourly model that built their entire professional identity may start to collapse. And beneath the resistance to adopting technology, beyond the talk of accuracy concerns, client trust, and risk management, I believe that there’s something simpler at play. If the hours disappear, so does the thing they’ve spent decades becoming. Strip away the time-and-materials or billable hours model for professional services teams, and many very accomplished people may not know what to do next.
This is what I call the “competence trap”, and it’s more dangerous than the confidence trap most leadership content talks about. Confidence is a feeling. Competence is a structure you build your entire professional life around. When that structure gets hollowed out by something faster and cheaper, you are at risk of losing the credential that made the room open for you in the first place.
The competence trap existed long before generative AI. It’s the executive who spent twenty years becoming the person who always has the answer and can’t tolerate a room where someone else’s answer is better. It’s the specialist who built a career on being the only one who understands a particular system and resists any change that would make that system understandable to everyone else. Competence, taken far enough, stops being a skill and has the unique potential of becoming a hiding place.
What something like Gen AI technology does is compress the timeline. It used to take a market shift ten years to expose how brittle a single-skill identity really was. Now it takes less than 12 months. The professional services workers who feel the ground move under them are behaving rationally. They’re behaving exactly like anyone would when the thing that made them valuable starts to look optional. The inertia everyone in the industry keeps writing about isn’t stubbornness or resistance.
I realized this problem years ago while building a practice from scratch. The people who fall into the competence trap aren’t protecting quality. They’re protecting the credential that made them feel like they had a right to be in the room. And the moment you’re doing that, you’ve already lost the thing that made you actually valuable.
In high-stakes contexts where validity matters and where right calls and wrong calls have real consequences, I have watched judgment get outsourced to systems, to processes, to whoever had the title that gave them authority to decide. The results were predictable: people stopped thinking, executing, and deferring instead. The moment the stakes rose higher than the system could handle, the entire structure collapsed.
Recently, I developed a framework called Human-as-the-KRINO™, and it emerged from that observation. The framework is built on a single principle: you stay in the judgment seat. Know what the tool or process is designed to do and what instructions shaped it. Review the output as material requiring your independent judgment before it becomes work product. Interrogate the methodology. Challenge the results. Run iterations. Test alternative framings. Normalize the output against what you actually know about the facts, the circumstances, the stakes. Own the determination. Own the work product. Own the accountability.
The acronym comes from the Greek word krinō, which means to judge, to discern, to separate the valid from the invalid. Because that’s what judgment is. It’s the act of discernment. And discernment is the credential that never becomes optional.
KRINO doesn’t care what tool is underneath. It works when you’re evaluating output from generative systems, when you’re overseeing work delegated to a team, when you’re making decisions in domains that haven’t changed yet but will. The framework is technology-agnostic because it’s not about the technology. It’s about staying in control of judgment itself.
The reason it resonates with people across every vertical is simple: they recognize themselves. They recognize the moment when they realized they’d built a credential around knowing how to do one specific thing in one specific way. And they recognize the terror of watching that become optional.
KRINO gives them a name for the thing that actually can’t be automated, outsourced, or compressed by technology. It’s the act of judgment itself. It’s the discipline of staying curious, flexible, and rigorously in charge of what you decide.
This is empowerment. Period. Not confidence. Not technical mastery. Empowerment is the refusal to surrender judgment, regardless of what changes around you.
If you are planning summer 2027 travel, I have something worth your time. In July of 2027, I will be on an AmaWaterways river cruise sailing the Rhine from Amsterdam to Basel. Seven nights. Rhine Castles. Swiss Alps. Brodie, my wife and luxury travel designer at M. Markham Travel, has secured exclusive preferred rates on this specific sailing just for GSL readers and listeners. Come find me on the deck. Bring whatever you are working through. We will talk.
See the full itinerary and lock in your rate at mmarkhamtravel.com/GSL
I believe that through my professional career arc, I have built value through something that is more portable than hourly expertise: a thought leadership tentpole made up of speaking, writing, podcasting, and framing problems for people who are too close to see them clearly. That work has followed me into every industry I’ve entered because the underlying skill was never the subject matter. It was the ability to make complexity legible and to hold the judgment seat about what mattered most.
I trained for a marathon with a strict rule: I refused to let myself cross a finish line without already knowing what came after it. Not because arrival is bad, but because I’ve watched what happens to people who fight with everything they have to reach a single goal, only to discover there is nothing on the other side. A person I knew fought hard to get a company to a sale, walked away with real money, and then had no idea what to do with himself. The goal had been the entire identity. When it ended, he didn't know what to do next.
That’s the lesson underneath the competence trap. It’s not enough to be excellent at one thing. You have to build the muscle of becoming something else before you’re forced to.
If the thing you’re known for disappeared tomorrow, if the world simply stopped valuing the credential that got you into the room, what would you actually have left? Not your title. Not your rate. What judgment, what discernment, what way of seeing problems would still make you worth having in the room?
If the answer takes you a while to find, that’s not a failure. That’s the trap making itself visible and worth acting on today.
The work now is building the answer before the market asks the question for you. KRINO gives you the methodology. Stay curious. Keep interrogating. Normalize against what you know. Own what you decide. The credential that survives every market shift is the one grounded in your refusal to outsource judgment itself. When information is abundant, real knowledge, skill, and expertise will, in fact, be the biggest differentiators.
I look at the long arc of a career through a single lens: what actually survives when you walk out of the room for the last time? Nobody looks back at a life and praises someone for mastering a static skill and defending it for forty years. The parts of a career that matter are the moments you stayed in the judgment seat, became who the world needed you to be, and refused to let a system convince you that your job was just to execute.
That’s the version of yourself worth building. Everything else is just a temporary container for it.
Evolving Beyond the Billable Hour: Listen to Ep. 51: AI Governance and Professional Identity
A look at how legal professionals can navigate shifting technology without losing their professional value.
Building Portable Leadership Skills: Listen to Ep. 58: Framing Complexity
Focus on the communication and problem-framing muscles required to remain highly valuable in any room, regardless of market changes.
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.