The fastest route to excellent work is to stop trying to make excellent work. A pottery classroom proved it.
If you’ve been sitting on an idea until it’s perfect, this story is for you.
On the first day of class, a pottery instructor divided his students into two groups.
The first group would be graded on quality. Their assignment: spend the entire semester creating one perfect pot.
The second group would be graded on quantity. Fifty pounds of pottery earned an A, forty pounds a B, and so on. Perfection didn’t matter—only output.
At the end of the semester, something unexpected happened.
The best pots didn’t come from the students chasing the one perfect masterpiece.
They came from the students who had made dozens of imperfect ones.
While the quality group spent months planning, debating technique, and trying to avoid mistakes, the quantity group was learning through repetition. Every pot taught them something—what worked, what didn’t, how to improve. By semester’s end, their accumulated experience had produced work of extraordinary quality.
The story comes from Art & Fear by David Bayles and Ted Orland. It’s often repeated as if it were a documented experiment, but it’s better understood as a teaching story. That doesn’t diminish it. The lesson holds.
This idea extends far beyond pottery.
Authors get better by writing books. Entrepreneurs get better by launching companies. Investors get better by making decisions. Musicians get better by recording songs. Teachers get better by teaching classes.
In every creative endeavor, there is knowledge that cannot be acquired by thinking. It has to be earned through doing.
Yet too many talented people never begin, because they want their first attempt to be exceptional.
They wait for the perfect idea. The perfect business. The perfect product. The perfect book. The perfect time.
Meanwhile, someone else starts today, produces imperfect work, learns from it, and quietly surpasses the perfectionist who never ships.
Looking back, much of my career has followed the quantity philosophy.
I’ve written dozens of books and built multiple companies. Created scores of online courses.
Not every project succeeded. Some exceeded expectations; others quietly disappeared. But each one taught me something that made the next one better.
If I had waited until every course, every book, every business plan was perfect, most of them would never have existed.
Progress compounds. Experience compounds. Confidence compounds.
The pottery story teaches something deeper than “practice makes perfect.”
Making many things removes the fear of failure.
When every project has to be your masterpiece, the stakes become enormous. Every mistake feels catastrophic.
But when you’re on your twentieth project, mistakes become data.
You experiment more. You take calculated risks. You get more creative, because you’re no longer protecting a flawless record.
That freedom, ironically, is what produces exceptional work.
Whether you’re writing a book, building a business, learning an instrument, or simply trying something new, don’t focus on making your first effort perfect.
Focus on making your next effort.
And then the one after that.
Quality isn’t where you start. It’s where repeated action eventually takes you.
The best pot is rarely the first one.
It’s the one that comes after you’ve made fifty.
No posts

Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.