RSS Amplifier

Catholic Share · May 30, 2026

One Bible, Two Reformers, Two Opposite Answers — In Year 14

Read inOriginalenesdefrptjaittr
0
Sign in to vote or save

Godwin Delali Adadzie · Catholic Share

Friends,

I don’t usually open with a thesis this blunt. But this one I’ll stand behind without flinching: the Reformation was a total failure. Period.

Not “it had good intentions but went too far.” Not “it raised valid concerns.” A failure on its own terms — measured against the goals its own founders set.

Here’s the thing nobody wants to say out loud. When Martin Luther nailed up his theses in 1517, he wasn’t trying to start 30,000 churches. He wanted to reform the one Catholic Church he was ordained in. To do it, he planted two seeds: sola scriptura (Scripture alone is the rule of faith) and private judgment (every believer interprets it for himself). Both sounded liberating. Both were fatal.

Why? Because the Bible never lists its own books. Luther only knew the 27 books of the New Testament because the Catholic Church told him so — at Rome in 382, Hippo in 393, and Carthage in 397. He accepted the Church’s authority to hand him the canon, then rejected that same authority on nearly everything else. And the doctrine that only Scripture is authoritative? It isn’t found anywhere in Scripture. It fails its own test the moment you state it.

In my newest article, I lay the whole case out — historically, theologically, and honestly:

👉 Read it here: https://www.catholicshare.com/the-protestant-reformation-was-a-total-failure-period/

Within a single generation, the Reformation was eating itself. Luther and Zwingli met at Marburg in 1529 to settle the meaning of the Eucharist. Both read the same four words — “This is my body.” Luther said Christ was truly present. Zwingli said it was only a symbol. They parted as enemies. One Bible, two reformers, two opposite answers — in year fourteen of the movement.

It only got worse from there. With no living teaching authority to settle disputes, force became the substitute. And five hundred years later, the fragmentation hasn’t stopped: at least 200 major Protestant denominations in the U.S. alone, tens of thousands worldwide, splitting in our own decade over the deepest questions of faith and morality. Same Bible, same century, opposite answers.

But Jesus prayed in John 17:21 that His followers would all be one — so that the world might believe. Unity was supposed to be the evidence. And here’s the part that seals it for me: even Protestant scholars are now admitting the failure. The Theopolis Institute, a Protestant think tank, has published openly that the Reformation failed in its core aim. When the obituary is being written by Protestants themselves, the case is closed.

Because some arguments land harder when you can hear them — when you can watch the timeline and see the pieces connect — I’m currently producing a full video version of this article. It’s in production right now and releasing soon. If you want to catch it the moment it drops, the best thing you can do is follow me in more than one place. Which brings me to something important.

Here’s the honest truth about the world we publish in: the algorithms decide what you see. You can follow me, hit every bell, subscribe to everything — and a platform can still quietly choose not to show you my work. One tweak to an invisible formula and an entire audience disappears overnight.

I’m not willing to let a black box stand between you and the fullness of the faith. So I’ve spread the mission across every platform I can, and I’d ask you to follow me on as many as you’re able. Redundancy isn’t paranoia — it’s how we stay connected no matter what any single platform decides.

Here’s where to find me:

  • 📬 Substack (you’re here!) — home base. Stay subscribed:

  • 🌐 CatholicShare.com — 2,700+ free articles on doctrine, apologetics, the saints, Scripture, and Catholic living:

https://www.catholicshare.com/

Pick two or three you actually use and follow me there. If one platform goes quiet, the others keep us connected.

I’ll be honest about the cost of this one. Telling this truth isn’t free — families, friendships, and decades of identity are bound up in Protestant communities, and plain words about the Reformation are rarely welcomed at first. But real love doesn’t soften the truth to keep the peace. The claim here isn’t that Protestants aren’t Christians; valid baptism makes anyone a Christian. The claim is narrower and sharper: the fullness of the faith Christ entrusted to the apostles lives in one visible Church — and that Church has been recognizable since the first century.

If this work has ever helped you or made you think, the most valuable thing you can do is share it. Forward this email. Send the article to the friend who keeps telling you the Reformation “fixed” the Church. Start the conversation.

The video is coming. The argument is ready. And I think it’s one worth having.

In Christ, Godwin Delali Adadzie

Founder & Editor, Catholic Share

Read the original on catholicshare.substack.com ↗

Comments

Nothing yet. Say the first thing.

    Sign in to join the conversation.