Middle school is a confusing time — for boys AND their parents!
It’s a time when boys pull away & pivot their attention to their peers. A time when grades, academic achievement, and organization seem particularly important (to parents) & not-at-all interesting (or important) to most boys. A time when misunderstanding between boys & parents can spark unnecessary conflicts that can consume the whole household with fire, metaphorically-speaking.
Avoiding conflict with your son during these years is next to impossible. (And also, not desirable. Boys learn a lot via conflict.) But understanding what’s normal, what’s developmental, and what boys actually need during this stage can help parents respond with more calm, confidence, and perspective.
That’s one of the reasons I was excited to connect with Jennifer & Corey, the parents behind Raising Middle School Boys, a Substack focused specifically on navigating these often-messy years. I asked them about what people misunderstand about middle school boys, what parents most need to know, and what boys themselves need most from the adults in their lives.
Here are their answers:
What do you think most people get wrong — or misunderstand — about middle school boys?
RMSB: The most common mistake is treating behavior as the story rather than reading it as information. A boy who is sullen, checked out, or picking fights is not a problem to be managed. He is communicating something for which he does not yet have the words. When adults respond to the behavior without curiosity about what is underneath it, they can miss the boy entirely.
The other thing people consistently underestimate is how much middle school boys still need the adults in their lives. They perform indifference remarkably well. But beneath the shrugs and the one-word answers is a kid who is watching closely to see who stays steady, who notices, and who keeps showing up even when he makes it challenging or downright difficult. The need for connection does not disappear at eleven. It just starts to go underground.
Help us understand what’s normal and typical for this age. What does typical 6th grade boy behavior look like at home and at school? How about 8th grade?
RMSB: A sixth-grade boy is often still straddling two worlds. He may still want to build things, roughhouse, and sit close to you on the couch, and then catch himself and reassemble into someone a bit more careful. He is beginning to feel the pull of peer approval intensely, but his identity is still porous enough that he has not fully committed to a social performance yet. At school, he is adjusting to a more complex social landscape, more teachers, more hallways, more chances to be seen or left out. At home, he may be louder, hungrier, and more emotionally reactive than he was a year ago. That is not regression. That is puberty arriving, and it is right on schedule.
By eighth grade, the performance is more polished. He has a clearer sense of where he fits socially, and he protects that position. He may be more private, quicker to shut down a conversation that feels too close, and more invested in his peer relationships than in anything happening at home. This can feel like distance, and sometimes it is. But it is also development. An eighth grader who is pulling toward independence while still gravitating toward you in unfamiliar situations is doing exactly what he is supposed to be doing. The goal at this stage is not closeness on your terms; it is staying available on his.
We know middle school is a time of transition for boys, but we don’t often talk about it as a time of transition for parents. What transitions will parents face during their boys’ middle school years?
RMSB: The hardest one, and the one parents usually seem least prepared for, is the shift from being needed to being chosen. When boys are small, your presence is simply assumed. Middle school is when they start deciding how much of you they want in the room. That recalibration is disorienting even when you know it is healthy.
Parents are also forced to grieve versions of their son that are quietly disappearing. The kid who wanted to tell you everything. The one who reached for your hand. He is not gone, but he is changing, and there is real loss in that even when the change is good. Parents who make room for that grief, rather than rushing past it, tend to handle the transition more gracefully. We will speak from our own experience here. Not long ago, we stumbled across an old video: our son at three years old, walking into Disney World, one small hand wrapped around his dad’s. Watching it stopped us both. That little voice. Those wide, completely unguarded eyes. That version of our boy is not coming back, and sitting with that truth for a moment actually hurt in a way that surprised us.
We loved him fiercely then, and we love the man he has become just as fiercely now. He is 22, a college graduate, and getting married in 45 days. By any measure, he is exactly who you hope your child becomes. And still, that little person belongs to a chapter that is finished, and there is real grief in that, even when everything is going beautifully. Perhaps especially when everything is going beautifully.
If you have felt that too, you are not being sentimental. You are being human. That grief is real, it is valid, and it takes as long as it takes.
And then there is the identity reckoning that happens in the adults themselves. Raising a boy through early adolescence has a way of surfacing your own unresolved experiences from that age: who you were in the hallway, where you fit, what you wish someone had said to you. That is not a problem. It is actually an opportunity, if you are paying attention.
In your experience, what do middle school boys most need from their parents?
RMSB: Presence that does not require a performance. Boys at this age are performing constantly, for their peers, for their teachers, sometimes even for themselves. Home should be the place where the performance is not required. That means tolerating the silence without filling it, staying in the room when things are hard, and making it clear through consistent action that your interest in him is not conditional on him being easy or impressive or okay.
They also need adults who are honest. Boys are watching to see whether the values you talk about are the ones you actually live by. They notice the gap between what you say and what you do much faster than most parents realize. Modeling accountability, including apologizing when you have gotten it wrong, teaches more than any conversation about integrity ever could.
And they need someone who is not afraid of this stage. Boys can feel when the adults around them are anxious or overwhelmed by their development. A parent who can stay curious rather than alarmed, who treats the hard moments as information rather than emergencies, gives a boy permission to be exactly where he is.
What do parents of middle school boys most need?
RMSB: Permission to be imperfect and reassurance that imperfect is enough. The research on this is actually quite comforting: what predicts good outcomes for boys is not precision parenting. It is consistent, warm, responsive presence over time. A parent who keeps showing up, who repairs after conflict, who stays curious about their son even when he is difficult, is doing the most important work there is. You do not have to get every moment right. You have to keep coming back.
Parents also need community. Raising a middle school boy can feel isolating, particularly when you are not sure whether what you are experiencing is normal. (It almost always is.) Finding other adults who are in the same season, who can offer a reality check or simply the comfort of shared experience, matters more than most parenting books do.
And honestly? They need someone to remind them to enjoy it. Not every moment of it, because some of it is genuinely hard. But the ordinary Tuesday evenings, the long stories that take twice as long as they should, the late-night conversations that start about nothing and end up meaning something. Those moments are happening right now, and they will not look exactly like this again.
What’s one thing you wish every parent of a middle school boy understood sooner?
RMSB: That your relationship with him is the intervention. Not the right consequences, not the right strategy, not the right script for the hard conversation. The relationship itself, maintained through consistency and warmth and a willingness to repair when it gets strained, is the most powerful thing you have. Every major protective factor in the research on adolescent boys points back to the same place: a consistent adult who notices, who stays, and who makes it clear through action that the boy matters. You are that adult. That is not nothing. That is everything.
Subscribe to Raising Middle School Boys
Thanks Jennifer & Corey!
Here’s to building boys, Jen
Highlights:
“Two decades ago, a landmark study showed that the brains of kids with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) take longer to mature. But new research suggests that this result, which was based on brain scans from a few hundred children, was a mirage.”
“What was thought to be a hallmark of the ADHD brain, the study found, instead reflects average sex differences in how the brains of boys and girls develop over childhood.”
Highlights:
“The behaviors associated with looksmaxxing look suspiciously like symptoms of eating disorders and body dysmorphia”
“Despite the widespread recognition that eating disorder-related content is harmful to mental and physical health, looksmaxxing has yet to be addressed by social media platform policies. Instead, prominent looksmaxxers are treated as internet celebrities”
I was Devastated to Learn I Was Having a Baby Boy. I’m Far From Alone.
Highlights:
“Whenever a well-meaning acquaintance or stranger asked whether I was having a boy or a girl, I didn’t even try to hide my displeasure: ‘A boy. Ugh.’”
“So much of my gender disappointment revolved around the chaotic scenes I’d witnessed involving young boys… My hormonal brain flashed to visions of a raucous toddler who wouldn’t stop climbing the walls while my best friend’s daughter calmly played with dolls”
“It turns out that my gender disappointment didn’t have anything to do with the baby in question. My baby is wonderful. All babies are wonderful. It’s us parents who have shit to work through.”
“the fear I heard echoed in almost every conversation: I don’t know what to do with a boy.”
“The stakes of raising your son wrong in this world are intimidatingly high…Unless we lock our sons in a room without an internet connection, they are sure to encounter misogynistic, racist messaging disguised as male empowerment on a daily basis.”
Contrary to Stereotypes, Gamers Tend to be More Inclusive Than the General Public, Study Finds
Highlights:
“The scientists…looked specifically at players of shooter games…[&] found that shooter game players were also more likely to hold inclusive values regarding gender roles and equality compared to the general public.”
“Across every model tested, the authors found no evidence that playing video games broadly corresponds to an increase in exclusionary values.”
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.