Parenting bright, sensitive, or intense kids can feel like a multi-year exercise in eating your own words. When your kid is differently wired, traditional parenting rules just don’t cut it. Caregivers in our gifted community groups often share that their best intentions were tossed out the window as soon as they realized their child was different; nearly all have had to chart a path not found in most parenting guidebooks.
Consider a few familiar scenarios:
The parenting books say to set firm boundaries, but negotiating with your bright preschooler gets them out the door without a meltdown.
You have an unusually mature fourth-grader, so you let them watch some PG-13 movies, while skipping some “kid” movies you know they’ll still find upsetting.
Your middle schooler becomes dysregulated whenever they’re forced to attend after-school activities, so you let them quit all extracurriculars.
Are you a “bad” parent for making any of these decisions? Of course not. Even if others don’t understand your reasoning, I’d argue that you’re acting as a highly responsive parent by attending to the needs of the child in front of you.
But it can feel like you’re a bad parent when you’re forced to make judgment calls that parents of typically developing kids either don’t have to make or might not understand. It’s even harder when you’re subjected to unsolicited advice about what you “should” be doing.
As far as parenting decisions go, those about screen time are some of the most agonizing. Much of the latest research, popular books, and even several recent lawsuits unequivocally conclude that digital technology—particularly social media—is bad for kids. While this issue is often presented in hyperbolic terms meant to scare parents, I do believe much of the research on the negative effects of social media and excessive device use is accurate for most kids.
In a perfect world, perhaps we wouldn’t have to stress about digital technology use at all because there would be abundant, free alternatives: easy access to parks and playgrounds, paid childcare to relieve overworked parents, alloparents like aunts, uncles, and neighbors (Lisa Sibbett writes beautifully about these!), and caring communities where children roam freely with friends after school.
But for many families, particularly in the United States, this is not their reality. The typical workday extends for two hours beyond the average school day, yet it’s considered suspicious for a child under 10 to play outside unsupervised. Many highly urban areas have no playgrounds, libraries, or gathering spaces where children are even permitted to exist. Alloparents are few and far between. And very few employers or states provide paid childcare or caregiver support. Our systems simply aren’t set up to support families and children in these ways.
Yet even when you do manage to find and afford alternatives to screens, when your kid is different, so is the calculus around device decisions. Maybe your child is highly demand-avoidant and will only do schoolwork on a device. Maybe they need assistive technology to communicate. Maybe the only place a profoundly gifted kid can find true peers is online. There are many legitimate reasons our kids end up using screens differently.
Yet when traditional parenting books and even the latest research don’t address the nuances of raising a gifted or neurodivergent child, many parents feel guilty, confused, and begin to question their own judgment.
That’s why today I’m sharing part one of a deeply researched, three-part deep dive for paid subscribers covering digital technology use with gifted kids. There is so much nuanced, important information I want to share with families, so it made sense to split this up over a few weeks.
I’d love to make this free, but it took a significant amount of time and energy away from my own family to create this series, so if you have $8.99 to spare, you’ll get access to all three parts over the next month, plus access to my entire library of 40+ research-backed articles on giftedness.
Today, I’m sharing:
Why gifted kids use and consume media differently
What we know about the impacts of screen time for bright kids specifically
In part two, I’ll cover:
The digital learning programs, tools, and products I actually recommend
Strategies for deciding which devices, programs, and media deserve a spot in your family’s life
And in part three, I’ll share:
How to create a media ethic and guidelines for your family
How to actually get your kids on board with the plan
It should be stated that most children enjoy consuming media, but gifted children’s relationships to screens are often quite different from those of more typical peers. Indeed, many parents of neurodivergent kids report that their children are like moths to the flame of television, video games, and handheld devices. There are both biological and practical reasons for this:
Children with ADHD show differences in dopamine signaling and reward processing, which may make highly stimulating activities, including using screens and devices, especially compelling.1 Autistic children often use devices to dive deeply into their special interests, and parents commonly report that screen time functions as a tool for decompression and emotional regulation.2 Children with disabilities often use technology to meet communication needs, access schoolwork, or interact socially.
Yet gifted children in particular are attracted to technology and screens for a few reasons many of us might not have realized, including:
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.