Why Your First Chapter Isn’t Working (And How to Fix It)

Material from Gala Russ novel writing course…

Your First Chapter Isn’t Setup. It’s a Promise.

Most first chapters fall flat when they explain instead of engage.

Your job isn’t just to “set things up” so the rest of the story can unfold, but to make a promise to the reader that you’ll fulfill and that reader want to stay around for.

Here’s how to check if your first chapter is doing that and what to fix if it’s not.

1. The Promise of the Story

Your first chapter should introduce the core tension of the book.

Not everything. Not the full plot.
Just enough for the reader to start asking:

What’s going to happen here?

Action:

• Write down the main question your chapter creates.

• Then ask: Would a reader care enough to keep going to get that answer?

If the answer is no → your chapter is too vague or too safe.

2. Character & Care

Readers don’t need your character’s full story yet, but they need a reason to care about them now.

Show the reader:

• what they want

• what’s not working

• how they react to pressure

Action:

• Identify what your character wants in this chapter (even something small).

• Add friction to it if it feels too easy.

3. Entry Point

Are you starting the story too late? Too early?

Action:

· If you cut the first chapter, will the readers still understand what’s going on?

4. Genre, Tone, & Intended Audience

Your first chapter tells the reader what kind of story this is.

Action:

• Ask people to read your first chapter and tell you how would they categorize this book?

5. Scene Movement (Not Just Setup)

Even if you don’t have an inciting incident in your first chapter, something needs to happen: a goal (even small), conflict, a shift

Action:

• Identify the goal in your opening scene.

• Then ask: What gets in the way?

• Then: What changes because of it?

6. The Chapter Question

What keeps the reader reading this chapter?

Action:

• Write the question your reader is asking while reading.

• Make it more concrete if it feels fuzzy.

Example: “Will she get the money in time?”

7. Backstory vs Momentum

Backstory slows your down unless it earns its place.

It should:

• change how we see the present

• or increase tension

Action:

• Highlight every piece of backstory.

• Ask: Does this change the meaning of what’s happening right now?

If not, then cut or move it.

8. Change by the End

Something must be different at the end of Chapter 1.

If not, the reader feels like nothing happened.

Action:

• Compare your first page to your last page of the chapter.

• What has changed?

If the answer is “not much” then you need a stronger shift

A strong first chapter does three things:

• makes a promise

• builds connection

• creates momentum

If one of those is missing, the chapter will feel off even if the writing is good.

Comp Titles Interview Recording + Workbook: https://writingconversations.thrivecart.com/comp-titles/

Write Your Novel Deep Dive:
https://writingconversations.thrivecart.com/wyn-deep-dive/

Write Your Novel (Summer Edition):
https://writingconversations.thrivecart.com/wyn-summer-2026/

Edit Your Novel Checklist for genre fiction writers: https://bethbarany.thrivecart.com/edit-your-novel-checklist/

Join the Edit Your Future: Science Fiction/Fantasy Revision Lab membership: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2012061/subscribe