When you start out in a PM role, people come to you for things in your remit. A client has asked for something. A user gave this feedback. A senior stakeholder wants to explore a new idea. You handle it - that’s the job.
The shift happens later. People start asking you things that go outside your normal remit. What do you think of this other product? How would you approach this problem? Can you show me how you did that? Can we collaborate on something?
Sometimes it turns into more than a work conversation. That is fine - that is also part of it.
That shift does not happen because you managed up well or built a deliberate stakeholder strategy. It happens because of something that’s not often discussed in newsletter posts or on LinkedIn.
The structural problem
The PM role is unusual. You are accountable for outcomes, but you cannot direct the people who create them.
Engineers report to an engineering manager. Designers report to a design lead. Legal, data, marketing, customer success - none of them are obligated to help you. You can write the world’s best product brief and still have nothing happen if the right people do not move.
Everything you achieve as a PM is through influence. That is not a complaint about the role. It is just the reality of how it works.
The implication is that influence is not optional. It is the mechanism. And yet most PM content treats it as a secondary concern - something you pick up along the way, after the frameworks.
Earned, not engineered
There is no shortage of advice on how to “build influence.” Manage up. Create allies. Control your narrative. Most of it is tactical.
Tactics can work in specific interactions. But they have a ceiling - and people can feel when they are being worked on.
The most durable form of influence is not built by trying to build it. It comes from how you show up consistently, across enough interactions, over enough time. Eventually, the direction of travel flips. Instead of you seeking buy-in, people bring things to you.
You cannot engineer that. Trust compounds from genuine interactions, not manufactured ones.
Like this post so far? Product Notes is a free weekly newsletter for product people. Subscribe to get it in your inbox.
The qualities that create it
There is no shortcut here. But there are specific things that show up consistently in PMs who earn it.
Approachable
You know you have got this right when people stop prefacing questions with “this is probably a stupid question.” That preface is a signal - it means someone is still a little unsure whether they will be dismissed.
The fact that they still ask, even with the preface, might mean you are already partway there. But the goal is for that qualifier to disappear entirely. People just ask.
That only happens if they have learned, through enough interactions, that you will hear them out. That no question gets treated as a waste of your time.
Firm but fair
When you say no, people accept it. Not because they have to, but because they trust your reasoning.
A big part of this is being consistent. If you give the same answer whether the CEO is in the room or not, if you do not bend your position under pressure without new information, people learn that your view is your actual view. They stop trying to find the angle that will change your mind, because they have learned there is not one.
It also means giving reasons, not just a flat no. And it means calibrating how firmly you push back to the situation - saving your strongest reactions for the requests that genuinely warrant them. If you escalate everything to the same level, the escalations stop meaning anything.
Being factual rather than emotional helps too, even when that is harder than it sounds.
Honest and direct
Your opinion is worth seeking because it will not just tell people what they want to hear.
This is what makes people come to you for a second opinion. They already know what the easy answer is. They come to you because they trust you to give them the real one - even when that is uncomfortable.
Human
You treat people like people. Under pressure, in difficult conversations, when things are not going well.
This sounds obvious. It is not universally common, and people notice.
The harder case - senior stakeholders
This model has one real limit: it requires enough interactions to compound.
With the people you work alongside every day, trust builds gradually and naturally. With senior stakeholders, the conditions are different. You see them less. They have less time. In some cases, you have one shot to make a point land - and if you do not get to it quickly, you have lost them.
This is just the reality of how senior stakeholders operate. The currency is different too - they are thinking about strategic impact, risk, business outcomes - not the day-to-day layer where relationships tend to develop first.
What helps is being more intentional about the touchpoints you do have. Show up before you need something. Share something relevant unprompted. Ask for input when the stakes are low. When you do have their attention, get to the point quickly - because you may not get a second run at it.
The goal is the same as everywhere else - enough genuine interactions for trust to build. It just takes longer, and requires a bit more thought about when and how to create them.
In summary
Influence for a PM is not about being liked.
It is about being consistently the kind of PM that people find worth their time. Approachable enough that they come to you early. Honest enough that they trust your opinion. Consistent enough that they know where you stand.
You cannot manufacture it. But you also do not have to be strategic about it. Show up the same way in every interaction - and over time, the influence follows.
Product Notes is free and lands every week. Subscribe to get it in your inbox.
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.