Reading · Author Mahi Mistry

Caleb

“This sucks,” I said, testing Kyle’s silk tie that was tightened around my wrists behind my back. My pout deepened when Kyle removed my pants and eyed me like he wanted to eat me.

“Come closer and I’ll suck you off,” I smirked, looking at the tent in his boxers, but Anna pinched my cheek, stealing my attention.

We had gone on a date to celebrate her pregnancy and decided to spend the night at my house with Alice staying at her aunt’s house. I had already planned a weekend to take her to Disneyland and get her anything she wanted.

I wanted to spoil Alice and couldn’t wait to hold the baby that was growing inside Anna.

“You promised to behave,” Anna reminded me, strutting in her slutty black lace lingerie. Her ass looked so fucking perfect and juicy in the thong. I wanted to bite it.

“I’m behaving,” I said, keeping my butt on the chair. “I let you guys put me on the cuck chair and tease me.”

I didn’t like losing control in the bedroom, but I couldn’t ignore my hot older girlfriend’s wish, especially when my boyfriend was going to tease me.

Kyle lowered my boxers, making me groan when my cock jumped out, tip leaking. His hand wrapped around the shaft, and I shifted when his brown doe eyes peered at me. He looked so pretty on his knees.

“Take it in your mouth,” I said, wishing I could curl my hands in his hair.

“No,” he replied as Anna joined him, kissing him, her long hair covering her face, making me test just how tight they had tied the knot.

I groaned when Anna kissed the tip of my head before sucking me. They were testing my patience when he joined her, two of them giving me a blow job at the same time. My abs were tensed and balls full as they took time taking me in their hot mouths, and it was so fucking messy, I wanted to paint their faces with my cum and then make them lick it off of each other.

“Fuck,” I gasped when they both pulled away with evil grins. “Why’d you stop? I’m close. Put your mouth back on my cock.”

They ignored me and stood up as Kyle took Anna to the bed in front of me. “Sorry, Caleb. You’ll have to wait,” he said, making out with her and slowly removing her lingerie.

“You both are gonna pay,” I warned them, growing harder at the sight of my boyfriend’s long dick fucking my girlfriend. The scent of sex hovered in the air as they moaned and groaned, teasing each other and watching me. Sounds of wet slaps of skin filled the room and I had enough.

I removed my hands from the tie and pounced on them. Kyle groaned when I bit his neck and pushed his ass, so he filled up Anna’s pussy. They both moaned, Kyle twisting to look at me as I pulled out a couple of things from my drawer.

“How did you get out?”

I dropped the bottle of lube beside Anna and tore a foil packet, covering my dick. “Your knot was lousy,” I replied and spanked his ass. I smiled at the sound of his grunt and poured lube over my fingers and his crack. He shivered when I prepared him for my dick with my digits.

“You ready?” I asked him, lining myself over his tight hole and as soon as he consented, I was pushing in.

They both groaned when my dick stretched his tight ring of muscle. I squeezed his hip and kissed his back, praising him for taking me so well. After a couple of thrusts, I was fully in and grunting at the squeeze of his tightness around me.

“You feel so fucking good,” I said to him, grabbing his hips and fucking him. “Keep fucking her.”

I didn’t have to tell him twice as he fucked her while I filled him up. Our groans echoed in the room, Anna clenching the sheets as she neared her orgasm. I could feel each clench of muscle as Kyle moved and came into her pussy, her orgasm making her whimper.

I bent him over her, holding the back of his neck as I used my full strength to fuck into him, biting my lip at the tightness. I met Anna’s wide gleaming eyes as I filled our boyfriend and mouthed her, I love you.

“Moan for me, pretty boy,” I told him, tightening my hold on his neck just a little as he grunted into Anna’s tits. “I want to hear your voice.”

“Caleb,” he moaned, his hands planting beside Anna’s head, trapping her underneath us so she could feel the thrusts too.

“I—fuck, I can’t,” he whimpered, the sound going straight to my balls as I increased my pace.

“Yes,” I groaned. “You can. Cum for me.”

His orgasm was small and short, but he filled up Anna again, making me grunt. I froze as my orgasm climbed until I was fucking into him and released inside the condom, his low groan making my toes curl.

“Fuck,” I sighed, slowly pulling out of him and rubbing his back when he shivered. Removing the condom, I got a clean rag to clean him up and give the proper aftercare to both of them as they lied pliant on the bed, basking in the post-coital bliss.

“That was amazing,” Anna whispered when we sandwiched her between the two of us. I kissed her neck, smiling at the warm flush of her body.

“Next time, I’m fucking your ass,” Kyle said, his glasses gleaming in the dim lights of the night lamp.

I smirked and said, “If you can pin me down and take me, I’ll give you my ass on a silver platter.”

His cheeks slashed with color, shaking his head at me and said, “One day, I will. Anna will help me, won’t you, angel?”

She hummed, her eyes closed as she buried her face in my chest, cuddling to me. I ran my hand through her hair as Kyle leaned closer, his fingers gliding over my arm.

“I never thought I’d find love after…” he trailed off, his hand entwining with mine as my gaze softened, staring at his pink swollen lips and kind eyes. “Especially with two people.”

“And that love is going to expand to a third someone,” I whispered, bringing his hand down to Anna’s stomach, who was fast asleep. “We are going to be fathers.”

“I have already set up a college fund for the baby,” Kyle confessed, his smile sweet as he caressed her stomach.

“Already?” I raised my brow. “I’ve enough money for as many kids as you want, but I’m glad.”

After a few breaths, he lifted his drowsy eyes to me when I gently removed his glasses. “Do you think we can give her twins?” He mumbled sleepily.

I chuckled and kissed his forehead. “Go to sleep. We can try for that tomorrow.”

He hummed lazily and snuggled Anna. I kept his glasses on the nightstand and looked at their peaceful sleeping faces, wondering how the hell I got so lucky.

I kissed their cheek, tucked them in and got cozy with them. Nothing made me feel safe than being in the arms of the two men I loved.

Bonus Scene 2:

Kyle

“I’m still unsure about it,” I said, eyeing Caleb’s death machine aka his motorcycle. I sighed when he put a helmet on my head and strapped it up, his lips curling.

“Don’t be a pussy,” he said in a sing-song voice and pulled me close. “I was a good boy when Anna was my backpack, so now it’s your turn.”

His body pressed against mine and the setting sun made shadows of his lashes on his cheeks. His shaved jaw felt perfect in my hand as I recently kissed his lips, humming at the taste of mint and cinnamon.

I tried to pull back to breathe, but his hand squeezed my ass, making me gasp, his kiss turning deeper. It made blood rush to my nether region. My hands clenched around his leather jacket as his tongue brushed against mine, the piercing on it reminding me how he had woken me up that morning.

“Fuck,” he breathed, pulling away and staring at me with hooded eyes. “I can’t get enough of you, Kyle.”

My cheeks reddened. I still couldn’t wrap my head around the fact that I was dating him and Anna and that we were expecting our child in eight months.

Clearing my throat, I stepped out of his hold and looked at my watch. “We need to leave now if we want to be on time.”

Caleb turned on the bike, the loud purr making my heartbeat increase. Taking a deep breath, I gingerly swung my leg over the seat, sitting down and clutching his jacket.

“Hold me tight,” he said, his voice muffled through the helmet visor. He looked over his shoulder and pulled my arms around his torso. “Tighter.”

I grumbled underneath my breath and braved myself for the ride. If Anna could do it, so could I. But something told me that he must have been very gentle riding with her—

A yelp escaped my lips when Caleb started driving the motorcycle and I felt the rumble of the engine through the seat, making me clench my legs. Holy shit. I tightened my hold on his body when he sped up, easily weaving through the traffic and entering the highway.

“Slow down!” I yelled as the wind brushed past our skin, my heart rate steadily increasing with the speed.

Caleb ignored me and my worst fear of him messing with me came to life. “Stop being so scared,” he said, and I could feel him grinning behind his stupid helmet. “I got you. You’re safe with me.”

Safe, my ass.

He was driving as if we were in some action movie and riding away from the cops.

“I want to get off!” I confessed, eyeing the trucks and bus as we moved past them.

He wasn’t driving recklessly. He was being cautious.

“Open your eyes, Kyle,” Caleb said, his hand tapping my thigh. “I know you’ve squeezed them shut.”

I didn’t reply, keeping them closed.

“Come on, you know I won’t do anything that you hurt you,” he said and I could hear the pout.

I clenched my jaw and replied, “Say that to my ass. You were rough the day before.”

Caleb chuckled and squeezed my thigh, making me swallow. Damn him. Why did he have to be so handsome and addictive? “I already apologized for that. Even gave you a sloppy-toppy to show how sorry I was, remember?”

I did remember. How his perfect lips had wrapped around me while Anna made out with me. Her soft tits were in my hands as our boyfriend went down on me.

“Whatever,” I mumbled and opened my eyes slowly.

My lips parted, and I was awe-struck at the scenery. Orange sunlight scattering through the empty road with woods on either side and a soft breeze brushing past us. It wasn’t too cold or hot, just the perfect weather with the warm setting sun.

“Beautiful,” I whispered, not realizing I had softened my hold on his torso.

His hand wrapped around mine in his lap. “Isn’t it?” He said, keeping the speed low as we both gazed at the scenery. “You like it?”

I hummed. “I like it.” With a small smile, I added, “Thank you for forcing me to ride with you.”

“You’re welcome, pretty boy,” he said with a soft chuckle. “You can thank me in other ways.”

“What other ways?”

Knowing him, I knew it meant something derogatory.

And I was right when he weaved his bike to a secluded part of the road with woods around us and asking me to get off.

“Are you gonna leave me stranded here?” I asked, my hands raising to unbuckle the helmet, but Caleb reached it first, removing it and claiming my lips in an urgent kiss.

“Maybe not,” he said between the clumsy kiss, our helmets dropping on the ground as he pressed against me and I felt the hardened bulge poking against my crotch that was sporting a semi. “Maybe you should show me what that mouth does if you want me to take you back home.”

My lips quirked. “Yeah?” I slid my hands under his tee-shirt, feeling the hard muscles. “You want to role-play as my captor? And I’m your damsel in distress?”

He sighed when my hands ran over his back and underneath his pants to squeeze his ass. “M-maybe,” he said, his eyes dropping to my lips. “I want to fuck you on this bike.”

I paused, my eyes going back and forth between the bike and him. “How is that even possible?” I said, pulling back and fixing my glasses. “Is it even strong—oomph!”

Caleb, that impatient jerk, pushed me on the bike, and surprisingly, it took our weight. “Why don’t we find out?” he breathed, his expert fingers running the zipper of my pants down and groping my cock from the boxers to pump it. “I already fucked Anna on the bike. Now it’s your turn.”

I groaned and moved my hips, trying to get the friction between his hand and my sensitive shaft. I felt his boner pressing against my ass and looked around to find the stranded road and creaky woods. Why was I getting turned on with the idea of doing it in public?

“When did you two…” I trailed off, my eyes going hazy, and looked down. I was leaning on the bike for support, his hand moving inside my pants at a leisurely pace, as if he had all the time in the world. “Caleb.”

He hummed, his hands pushing down my pants and boxers. “When you were in New York for work,” he replied, kissing my neck and turning me around. “We thought about you.”

I shucked off his jacket and stroked him through his underwear, his gasps and sighs turning me on. Our lips met in a clumsy kiss, his teeth pressing against my bottom lip as he squeezed and touched me everywhere. Our chiseled chest brushed against each other, our hard cocks bumping and making us moan. As much as I loved the feeling of Anna’s warmth and softness, I liked the stark difference between her and Caleb with his hard muscles and strength to overpower me.

“You feel so good,” I whispered against his swollen pink lips, his lip piercing, glistening as he stroked our cocks together in his hand.

I moaned when he brushed his thumb over my tip. “I want to make you feel good,” he whispered, his kisses trailing down my jaw to my neck and sucking.

I pulled back and gave him a stern look. “No hickies.”

He pouted but relented and pulled two packets from his jean pocket. “Will you be able to take it?” Caleb asked as I leaned on the warm leather of his bike and swallowed.

I know he wasn’t trying to be a show-off, but he was huge. With a thick girth that made me hiss in a pinch of pain even though he prepped me enough.

He saw the contemplating look on my face and said, “We can just fuck with our fist—”

I reached out to his hand and tore the packet of lube with my teeth and met his eyes. I said, “I can take it, big boy.”

His lips parted when I poured the lube over his cock and stroked him until he was red, his piercing making it look angry. I needed him. Wanted him.

“Be gentle,” I warned him and turned around, facing the woods.

I braced myself when he stepped behind me, his warm breath caressing my neck as he added more lube over my tight opening. I greeted my teeth when he lined himself against me, my dick pressing against the warm leather and pre-cum leaking over my belly-button.

“You look so fucking sexy right now,” Caleb groaned, pushing in slowly. “Wish Anna could see you—see us right now.”

I whimpered, clutching the bike and hoping it would hold our weight. “She would be so wet,” he continued, his voice lowering an octave. “Maybe you can help her out when I’m taking care of you, hm?”

“Y-yeah,” I replied, my glasses sliding down my nose. I could feel myself stretch to accommodate him and no matter how gentle he was, the fullness of him was pushing me to the edge. “Hurry, Caleb.”

His hand wrapped around my cock, pumping me slowly and making me whimper. “Shh, I got you. I don’t wanna hurt your cute ass, so have some patience,” he grunted, pushing in another inch. “You have no idea how much I want to bend you over and fuck you.”

“Do it,” I breathed out and leaned over, feeling uncomfortable and aroused. I had never thought about christening his bike, but the thrill of doing it in the woods where no one could hear us made me feel hot. “Fuck me.”

His hand squeezed my cheek before he slowly thrusted in making us both moan. My eyes rolled back when he bumped right against the sweet spot. I snapped back to reality when I felt a car roll closer and held my breath when I saw it was familiar.

“What is—aah!” I moaned, falling over, but Caleb caught me, fucking me with slow deep thrusts.

He hummed, rolling his hips. “I called her before bringing you here.”

Our hot girlfriend, Anna, walked towards in her pilates clothes that stuck to her curves like second skin. She must have driven straight from her classes with her hair in a ponytail. My lips parted in awe and a gasp when Caleb didn’t stop, even when she leaned over the bike to kiss him.

It felt embarrassing and hot to have her see me and Caleb like that.

“Hi boys,” she said, her sultry voice going straight to my tight balls. “Need any help?”

“Maybe Kyle here needs help,” Caleb suggested, slamming inside me and making me buck.

Anna listened to him, sliding beside us and caressing my hair. I melted in her embrace when she pulled me up to brush her lips over me. “You need help?” She asked, her voice low.

I nodded, kissing her and moaning in her mouth as our boyfriend fucked me on his bike. Her soft curves pressed against me and my head went blank as Caleb remained pressed against my back while she was in front, both of them sandwiching me in between.

Most of the time, it was Anna who was in that position.

“Want me to suck you off, Kyle?” Anna asked, her breasts in sports bra and jacket squishing against my chest.

I couldn’t deny as she kneeled on the ground with her jacket underneath her knees. I took a mental note to give her a massage later that night. My eyes drooped, watching her lick her lips and kiss the tip of my cock. I sighed when she took me in my mouth, Caleb’s stiffened member throbbing inside me.

“You both are so fucking perfect,” I whispered, leaning back on Caleb as our girlfriend sucked my dick like a champ. “Fuck—your mouth. I’m close, angel.”

She increased her pace, bobbing her head on me and taking me deeper just as Caleb filled me up and my hips jerked. I moaned with my release, pleasure rolling all over my body as white fiery lust poured out of me.

Anna swallowed it all, her cheeks red and eyes glistening with tears by the time she straightened up. I kissed her, mumbling sweet words as Caleb used his strength to fuck me until he orgasmed with his teeth dug into my shoulder.

He was like an animal until he pulled out and kissed me. “How are you feeling, handsome?”

I hummed when he caressed my hips. “I’m good.” I eyed Anna, who was looking between us, her hazel eyes full of lust. “I think she wants us.”

“I… I’m tired after my class and—mmgh, Caleb!”

Anna

Caleb pounced on me, making Kyle chuckle. I leaned into his kiss and sighed when he pressed closer. I had missed them and seeing them have sex in the wild had made me extremely wet.

I wasn’t expecting it when Caleb had asked me to go through the secluded road and made a stop in the woods. But it was a pleasant surprise.

More than nice.

Kyle’s lips captured mine, and I kissed him back, moaning when a hand slid under my leggings to brush over my soaked panties.

“She’s drenched,” Kyle whispered, pulling back to look at Caleb. “Why don’t you help her out?”

I licked my lips when Caleb followed his command and kneeled on the ground. He didn’t waste any time to remove my leggings and underwear, and they both groaned at the sight of my sex. I yelped when Kyle lifted me to have me sit on the bike as Caleb threw my legs over his shoulder and leaned close.

“Such a pretty pussy, mama,” Caleb whispered, rubbing his fingers over my slicked lips, making me squirm. But Kyle held me, his hands pulling down my bra to kiss my tits, making me gasp. “It is our pussy, isn’t it, pretty?”

“Yes,” I moaned when his lips wrapped around my clit, his lip and tongue piercing, making it hard to think.

“That’s right,” Kyle whispered, biting my nipple and making me whimper. Caleb inserted two fingers inside me and curling them just right and making me buck against his hot mouth.

“All ours,” Caleb said, fucking me with his fingers as his tongue brought me to the edge.

Kyle’s hand cupped my face, kissing me slowly. “Cum for us, angel.”

I moaned into his mouth when Caleb increased his pace. Pleasure flooded my veins, my stomach tensing and breathing turning heavier as I felt myself close and fall over the edge.

Lust blinded me, my eyes squeezing shut. But I had two hot and handsome young boyfriends who were taking care of me when I came back down to earth.

One rubbing my back and saying sweet nothings in my ear, praising me for doing so well while the other helped me back into my clothes, demanding for round two in my car.

“I’m sore,” I said, ignoring Caleb’s pout, and thanked Kyle when he took my jacket.

“I’ll drive her home,” Kyle said, patting my head. “I don’t think she’ll be able to drive right now.”

Caleb spanked his butt, making me smile. “And what about you? Your ass just—”

Kyle gave him a stern look. “Meet us at home, Caleb. Don’t get too greedy.”

“Meanie,” he said with a pout and leaned in to kiss us both. “First to reach home gets his wish fulfilled.”

He didn’t let us speak and got on his bike, wearing the helmet and driving out of the woods.

We both chuckled. “He really wants a round two,” Kyle said, opening the passenger door for me and strapping the seat belt for me. “Are you okay?”

I squeezed his hand when he started the car and smiled. “I’m more than okay. I have two hot boyfriends, after all.”

“I’m so lucky to have you both.” His eyes softened behind his glasses as he pressed his lips on my forehead. “Let’s get home or he won’t stop pouting.”

I had a silly grin on my lips as we drove home.

My heart felt full. I was lucky to have them, Kyle and Caleb.