We’ve been walking alongside several broken-hearted parents lately. Their young adult children have embraced beliefs very different from their own—some political, some about sexuality or gender identity. These choices often conflict with their parents’ faith and values.
These differences have led to sleepless nights, difficult conversations, and strained relationships. But here’s what’s really breaking these parents’ hearts: It’s not the choices themselves. It’s the ultimatum that follows.
Their children are demanding that parents not just accept their choices but agree with them. The message is clear: “If you love me, you’ll agree with my decisions. If you don’t agree, we can’t have a relationship.”
The Cultural Lie: “Love Means Agreement”
Our culture increasingly insists that we can’t love someone with whom we disagree. Political groups and social movements spread this message to rally supporters against opponents. But it’s most devastating in families, where young adults—already working to establish independence and earn respect—are especially vulnerable to this idea.
At this stage of life, young adults often feel insecure, even while projecting confidence. They’re desperate to prove they’re mature and competent. Any challenge feels like disrespect. So, when culture tells them, “Disagreement equals disrespect equals lack of love,” they believe it.
As parents, we’ve always heard “If you loved me...” when our kids wanted more dessert or a later curfew. But this is different. Back then, they weren’t questioning our love—just testing boundaries. And we loved them enough to say no to what would harm them.
Now the world teaches that love and agreement are the same thing.
That’s just foolish, harmful, and wrong.
What the Bible Says About Love and Disagreement
Scripture tells us that every person has sinned. We’ve all chosen our will over God’s will. We disagreed with God. He disagreed with us. But he never stopped loving us.
When I fail today—when I’m selfish or miss the mark—I don’t stop loving God, and he doesn’t stop loving me.
If love required agreement, there would be no need for grace, mercy, forgiveness, accountability, or correction. These are all biblical concepts that only make sense when love transcends disagreement.
The foundational truth is this: Love is not dependent on agreement or acceptance.
“We love because he first loved us.” (1 John 4:19)
God loved us before we loved him back, before we agreed with him, before we even knew him.
How Should Parents Respond?
1. Remove the log from your own eye first.
Jesus asks in Matthew 7:3, “Why do you see the speck in your brother’s eye, but not the log in your own?” He’s not saying we have the same sin we’re judging. He’s saying something is keeping us too far away to help or be trusted with tender, vulnerable issues. That something is usually pride and fear.
Prayerfully deal with your own pride and fear first. Then you can get close enough to navigate the most painful circumstances. Without this step, your extension of love may be interpreted as conditional.
2. Accept your changing role.
Your children are adults now. You can’t control their behavior like you did when they were young. That’s not your role anymore.
Your calling now is to reflect God’s character through the fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. This often means confronting the emotion that triggers our worst reactions faster than any other: embarrassment.
3. Don’t confuse acceptance with agreement.
Agreeing with what contradicts God’s Word is not love—even when refusing feels impossible.
There’s a difference between graciously accepting the reality of your children’s decisions and agreeing with those decisions. If you pretend to agree while disagreeing inside, you hurt everyone:
You reinforce an unhealthy way of handling conflict
You create damaging internal conflict in yourself
You model dishonesty in relationships
The Path Forward
Love unconditionally.
Accept consequences beyond your control.
Without agreeing—or pretending to agree—with what God has deemed destructive.
This is the narrow, painful path. But it’s the one that honors both truth and love.
Thanks for Reading,
John
Thanks for reading 7 Prodigals! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Comments
Nothing yet. Say the first thing.
Sign in to join the conversation.